跳到主要內容

簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 李季光
論文名稱: 邊沁 : 功利.自由與民主
指導教授: 江金太
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 社會科學學院 - 政治學系
Department of Political Science
論文出版年: 1983
畢業學年度: 71
論文頁數: 178
相關次數: 點閱:266下載:0
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 本文從「普遍利益與個人利益之關係」這一角度,研究邊沁關於功利原則、自由、民主這三個概念的主張,貫穿全文的一項基本假定是:

    「邊沁政治思想的重點,在於如何透過制度改革,達到兼顧普遍利益與個人利益的目的,個人利益指向個人價值,普遍利益指向社群整體的秩序,亦即如何在不侵害個人價值的前提下,維持社群秩序,以及在不損及社群秩序的同時,使個人價值得以確保。」

    由此一基本假定,衍生為下列各章研究的重點:

    第一章的研究要點在說明本文研究之目的與範圍,並討論有關資料,以指出邊沁生處的時代環境對其思想的影響。

    第二章的研究重點在指出邊沁以人性趨樂避苦,作為功利原則的實然基礎,以行為後果的苦樂做為善惡判斷的標準,道德計算則是調和人性實然與行為應然的方法。另一方面,普遍利益乃功利原則的另一說法,而調和個人利益與普遍利益,即是調和個體價值與整體秩序之間的關係。

    第三章的研究重點在指出邊沁對自由採消極性定義,自由不復為一自然權利,而是由法律所保障的安全,亦即免於個人與政治權力侵犯的保障,而出版與集會自由則是免於政治權力濫用的救濟之一。

    第四章的研究重點在探討最大多數人的最大幸福之原則,與代議民主的關係,以指出就人性實際面而言,統治者必追求一己私利,而理想的政府目的應是最大多數人的最大幸福;為求調和這實然與應然的衝突,代議民主乃成為必需的制度。

    第五章除提出筆者個人研究心得外,並嘗試將邊沁的思想做一綜合評論。


    第一章 導論1
    第一節 研究目的與範圍1
    第二節 邊沁政治思想的時代背景5
    附錄:研究資料9
    第二章 功利原則15
    第一節 功利原則的立論15
    第二節 個體利益與普遍利益30
    第三章 自由59
    第一節 無限制的自由61
    第二節 自由即安全70
    第三節 出版與集會自由83
    第四章 民主107
    第一節 應然:最大多數人的最大幸福109
    第二節 實然:統治少數的最大幸福121
    第三節 實然與應然的連結:代議民主134
    第五章 結論155
    第一節 個人心得155
    第二節 評論161
    參考書目167

    壹、書籍
    (一)中文部份
    1.江金太,歷史與政治(台北:桂冠,民國七十年)初版。
    2.周德偉,功效主義重詁(作者自行出版)
    3.浦薛鳳,西洋近代政治思潮(台北:中華文化出版事業委員會,民國四十二年)
    4.Robert Nisbet 著,徐啟智譯,西方社會思想史(台北:桂冠,民國六十八年)
    5.張家鳳,邊沁的政治思想研究(中國文化學院政治研究所碩士論文,民國六十三年)未出版
    6.鄒文海,西洋政治思想史稿(台北:鄒文海先生獎學基金會,民國六十一年)初版。
    7.Bertrand Russell 著,鍾建閎譯,西方哲學史(台北,中華文化出版事業委員會,民國四十四年二月)初版。
    (二)英文部份
    1. Baumgardt David , Bentham & the Ethics of Today (New York : Princeton University Press 1952 )
    2. Bentham , Jeremy , The Works of Jeremy Bentham ( Edinburgh : Tait , 1838-1848 , repr. Russell & Russell Inc., 1962 )
    3. Bentham , Jeremy, A Fragment on Government & An Introduction to the Principles of Morals & Legislation , ed., Wilfrid Harrison ( Oxford : Basil Blackwell, 1948 )
    4. Bentham , Jeremy, The Limits of Jurisprudence Defined, ed, C.W. Everett (Westport Connecticut : Greenwood Press , 1970 )
    5. Bentham , Jeremy Bentham’s Handbook of Political Fallacies , revised by Harold A. Larrabee ( New York : Thomas Y. Crowell Company , 1971 )
    6. Bowie Norman E. & Robert L. Simon, The Individual & the Political Order : An Introduction to Social & Political Philosophy ( New Jersey : Prentice-Hall , Inc., 1977 )
    7. Bronowski , J. & Bruce Mazlish , The Western Intellectual Tradition : From Leonardo to Hegel(台北:大同圖書公司,民國五十八年)
    8. Coker Francis W., Recent Political Thought ( New York : Appleton- Century - Crofts, Inc., 1934 )
    9. Flathman Richard E., The Public Interest : An Essay Concerning the Normative Discourse of Politics ( New York : John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1966 )
    10. Gunn , J. A. W., Politics & the Public Interest in the Seventeenth Century( Toronto : University of Toronto Press, 1969)
    11. Halevy, Elie , The Growth of Philosophic Radicalism ( Boston : The Beacon Press, 1960 )
    12. Hamburger , Joseh , Intellectuals in Politics : John Stuart Mill & the Philosophic Radicals(New Haven : Yale University Press, 1965 )
    13. Held , Virginia , The Public Interest & Individual interests ( N. Y. : Basic Books , Inc., 1970 )
    14. Jones , W. T., Masters of Political Thought (Boston : Houghton Mifflin Company , 1966 ) Vol. Ⅱ.
    15. Laski, Harold J., Political Thought in England : Locke to Bentham ( N.Y : Oxford Univ. Press 1920 )
    16. Letwin , Shirley , The Pursuit of Certainty (Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press , 1965 )
    17. Lively , Jack & Rees John ( eds. )Utilitarian Logic & Politics : James Mill’s " Essay on Government", Macaulay’s Critique & the Ensuing Debate ( Oxford : Clarendon Press, 1978 )
    18. Long, Douglas G., Bentham on Liberty : Jeremy Bentham’s Idea of Liberty in Relation to His Utilitarianism ( Tornoto & Buffalo : the University of Tornoto press, 1977 )
    19. Lyons, David, In the Interest of the Governed : A Study in Bentham’s Political Philosophy of Utility & Law ( Oxford : Oxford Univ. Press, 1973 )
    20. Mack , Mary P. , Jeremy Bentham : An Odyssey of Idea ( N.Y. : Columbia Univ. Press , 1963 )
    21. Manning , D. J., The Mind of Jeremy Bentham ( New York : Barnes & Noble , Inc., 1968 )
    22. Miller, S. T., British Political History 1784-1939 ( London : Mac Donald & Evans , 1977 )
    23. Parekh Bhikhu , Jeremy Bentham : Ten Critical Essays ( London : Frank Cass , 1974 )
    24. Parkinson , C. Northcote, The Evolution of Political Thought ( Boston : The Riverside press,1958 )
    25. Plamenatz , John , The English Utilitarians ( Oxford : Basil Blackwell , 1949 )
    26. Rawls, John A Theory of Justice (台北雙葉翻印本,民國六十八年)
    27. Rosenblum , Nancy L., Bentham’ s Theory of the Modern State ( London : Harvard University press, 1978 )
    28, Steintrager , James, Bentham ( London : George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1977 )
    29. Stephon, Leslie , The English Utilitarians ( London : Duckworth & Co, 1900 , repr. University of London Press, 1950 ) 3. Vols.
    30. Wanlass Lawrence G., Gettel’s History of Political Thought (台北:美亞,1972 )2nd. ed.
    貳、期刊、報紙與文章
    (一 )中文部份
    1.江金太,“再論盧梭:自然人與社會人”國立政治大學學報,四十六期,民國七十一年十二月。
    2.朱堅章,“浴克自由觀念之分析”國立政治大學學報,二十期,民國五十八年十二月。
    3.朱堅章,“盧梭政治思想中自由觀念的分析”國立政治大學學報,二十六期,民國六十一年十二月。
    (二)英文部份
    1. Ayer , A. J., " The Principle of Utility in A. J. Ayer , Philosophical Essays ( London : Macmillan & Co., 1954 ) pp. 250-270.
    2. Benditt Theodore M., " The Concept of Interest in Political Theory" Political Theory , Vol. 3, No. 3, August 1975 , pp. 245-258.
    3. Budge , Ian, " Jeremy Bentham : A Re-evalution in the Context of Empirical Social Science " Political Studies , Vol. xix , No.1, 1971 , pp. 18-36.
    4. Fisher , Mark , " Truth as a Problem for Utilitarianism " Mind , Vol. 89 , No. 354 , April 1980 , pp.249-255.
    5.Fitzsimons, Matthew A., " The English Tradition of Authority " in George N. Shuster ( ed. ) Freedom & Authority in the West ( London : University of Notre Dame Press 1967 ) pp. 107-126.
    6. Goldworth, Amnon, "Bentham’s Concept of Pleasure : Its Relation to Fictitious Terms" Ethics , Vol. 82 , No. 4 , July 1972 , pp. 334-343.
    7. Gunn , J. A, W., " Jeremy Bentham & the Public Interest " Canadian Journal of Political Science, Vol. I, No. 4 , Dec. 1968 , pp. 398-413.
    8. Heinberg , John Gilbert , "History of the Majority Principle "The American Political Science Review, Vol.. xx, No. 1 , February 1926 , pp. 52-68.
    9. Himmelfarb, Gertrude, " Bentharn’ s Utopia : The National Charity Company " Journal of British Studies , Vol. 10 , November , 1970 , pp. 80-125.
    10 James, Michael, " Public Interest & Majority Rule in Bentham’s Democratic Theory " Political Theory, Vol. 9, No. 1 , February 1981 , pp. 49-64.
    11. Kort , Fred, " The Issue of a Science of Politics in Utilitarian Thought " The American Political Science Review , Vol. xlvi , 1952, pp. 1140-52.
    12. Kramnick, Isaac, " Religion & Radicalism: English Political Theory in the Age of Revolution " Political Theory Vol. 5 , No. 4, November , 1977 , pp. 505-34.
    13. Niemeyer, Gerhart, " Public Interest & Private Utility " in Carl J. Friedrich ( ed. ) The Public Interest ( New York : Atherton Press, 1962 ) pp.1-13.
    14. Oppenheim, Felix E., " Self Interest & Public Interest " Political Theory , Vol. 3 , No. 3, August 1975 , pp. 259-276.
    15. Palmer, Paul A., " Benthamism in England & America " The American Political Science Review Vol. xxxv, No.5, October 1941 , pp.855-871.
    16. Parekh, Bhikhu , " Bentham’s Theory of Equality " Political Studies , Vol. xviii , No.4, 1970, pp. 478-495.
    17. Peardon, Thomas P. " Bentham’s Ideal Republic" Canadian Journal of Economics & Political Science, Vol. 18, 1951 , pp. 184-203.
    18. Roberts, David, " Jeremy Bentham & the Victorian Administrative State " Victorian Studies , Vol. 11 , No.3 , March 1959 , pp. 193-208.
    19. Rockow , Lewis, " Bentham on the Theory of Second Chambers " The American Political Science Review , Vol. xxii , No. 3, August 1928 , pp.576-590.
    20. Rosen, Fredrick, " Jeremy Bentham : Recent Interpretations " Political Studies , Vol. xxx, No.4 , 1983, pp. 557-581.
    21. Sartorius, Rolf, " Individual Coduct & Social Norms : A Utilitarian Account " Ethics , VoI. 82, No. 3 , April 1972 , pp. 200-218.
    22. Singer, Marcus G. " Actual Consequence Utilitarianism " Mind , Vol. 86 , No. 341 , January 1977, pp.67-77.
    23. Tarlton, Charles D. " The Overlooked Strategy of Bentham’s Fragment on Government " Political Studies Vol. xx, No.4, 1972 , pp. 397-406.
    24. Wallace, Graham, " Jeremy Bentham " Political Science Quarterly , Vol. 38 , March 1923 , pp. 45-56.
    25. Weinstein , W. L .," The Concept of Liberty in Nineteenth Century English Political Thought" Political Studies , Vol. xiii , No. 2 , 1965, pp. 145-162.

    無法下載圖示 (限達賢圖書館四樓資訊教室A單機使用)
    QR CODE
    :::