| 研究生: |
張佳雯 |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
論癮性商品之消費型態與政府管制 |
| 指導教授: | 徐偉初 |
| 學位類別: |
博士
Doctor |
| 系所名稱: |
社會科學學院 - 財政學系 Department of Public Finance |
| 論文出版年: | 2004 |
| 畢業學年度: | 92 |
| 語文別: | 中文 |
| 論文頁數: | 100 |
| 中文關鍵詞: | 理性上癮 、殊價財 、政府管制 、最適商品稅 |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:163 下載:36 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
本研究將針對癮性商品這個主題,分三部分來探討。第一部份討論癮性商品之長期消費型態與影響因素;第二部份討論癮性商品管制政策的方向;第三部份討論考慮癮性商品的最適商品稅。癮性商品的特性為當期該商品的消費數量,會受到其前期消費數量的影響,常見的例子為香菸、酒精與毒品等。論文的第一部份採取理性上癮假設,建立一個代表性消費者的跨期消費模型,採最適控制的方法以導出癮性商品的長期消費途徑。文中也進一步探討各種外在因素如何影響癮性商品的消費。我們得出的結果如下:若有未預料到的癮性商品價格上升,將使癮性商品的長期消費減少。若癮性商品的價格上升是可預料的,則在調整價格前癮性商品的消費會上升;但在調整價格後,癮性商品的消費仍會減少。政府提供較充分的癮性商品資訊,將可減少癮性商品的長期消費。時間偏好率較高者,癮性商品的長期消費會較多。
當癮性商品具劣價財性質時,消費者的健康風險認知將受扭曲,即使是追求個人的效用極大化的理性消費者,對癮性商品的消費決策仍將偏離個人最適與社會最適。政府適時的干預,將可改善資源配置與提高社會福利水準。 因此,在第二部份中我們將討論癮性商品管制政策的方向。政府可採直接管制,限制消費者每一期的癮性商品消費數量, 或藉由教育、提供資訊來改變個人的健康風險認知;政府也可採間接管制,提供經濟誘因使消費者自行修正對癮性商品的消費,最普遍的方式為租稅制度的調整。決定最適管制原則的因素包括:健康風險認知的扭曲程度、癮性商品存量對個人身心健康的影響、癮性商品存量的影子價格對癮性商品消費的影響、時間偏好率、折舊率,與癮性商品的價格彈性。
最後我們探討當經濟體系中存在癮性商品時,最適商品稅的課稅原則。在著名的最適商品稅理論 Ramsey rule中,主張商品稅的稅率應與課稅所造成之補償性需求的負面影響成反比。然而由於癮性商品具有跨期消費相關的性質,考慮癮性商品之最適商品稅顯然將更為複雜。本文延續第一部份所建構之代表性消費者的跨期消費模型, 藉由代表跨期間接效用的 Bellman value function,求導政府固定稅收目標下的最適間接稅結構。 根據模型推導所得到的課稅原則如下:當癮性商品存量的影子價格大於零時,代表癮性商品存量的累積將對個人身心健康產生正面影響。此時應對癮性商品及其具效用互補性的一般商品課較低的稅率,並應對其具效用替代性的一般商品課較高的稅率。當癮性商品存量的影子價格小於零時,代表癮性商品存量的累積將對個人身心健康產生負面影響,此時應對癮性商品及其具效用互補性的一般商品課較高的稅率,並應對其具效用替代性的一般商品課較低的稅率。此外,最適租稅稅率的訂定仍須衡量課稅使長期所得下降的幅度、癮性商品存量的影子價格, 與癮性商品存量的價格敏感度等因素。
書名頁
摘要
1 緒論
1.1研究目的
1.2研究架構
2 論癮性商品之長期消費型態與影響因素
2.1前言
2.2理論模型
2.2.1基本設定
2.2.2動態最適條件
2.2.3比較靜態分析
2.2.4癮性商品長期消費型態
2.3均衡調整與比較
2.3.1未預料到的價格上升
2.3.2預料到的價格上升
2.3.3提供資訊的影響
2.3.4時間偏好率的影響
2.4本章結論
3 癮性商品之管制政策
3.1前言
3.2癮性商品的殊價財與劣價財性質
3.3癮性商品的最適管制
3.3.1政府管制目標
3.3.2認知錯誤的消費均衡
3.3.3最適管制政策
3.4管制後消費行為的動態分析
3.4.1未預料到的從量稅
3.4.2預料到的從量稅
4 考慮癮性商品之最適商品稅
4.1前言
4.2個人的跨期消費模型
4.2.1基本模型與均衡
4.2.2跨期間接效用函數
4.3最適商品稅
4.3.1 Ramsey rule
4.3.2最適商品稅課稅原則
4.3.3最適商品稅的租稅架構
4.3.4影響最適商品稅結構的因素
4.3.5模型比較
4.4本章結論
5 結論
5.1研究結果
5.2研究限制與展望
參考文獻
傅祖壇、劉錦添、簡錦漢與賴文龍(2001),
`健康風險認知與香菸消費行為-台灣實證研究',經濟論文,第29卷,第1期, pp.91-118.
Atkinson, Anthony B. and Joseph E. Stiglitz (1972),
`The structure of indirect taxation and economic efficiency', Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 1, pp.97-119.
Basu, K. (1988),
`Retrospective choice and merit goods', Finanzarchiv, Vol. 34, pp.220-225.
Baumol, William J. and David F. Bradford (1970),
`Optimal departures from marginal cost pricing', American Economic Review, Vol. 60, pp.265-283.
Becker, Gary S.,Michael Grossman and Kevin M. Murphy (1994),
`An empirical analysis of cigarette addiction', American Economic Review, Vol. 84, pp.396-418.
Becker, Gary S. and Kevin M. Murphy (1988),
`A theory of rational addiction', The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 96, pp.675-701.
Besley, Timothy (1988),
`A simple model for merit good arguments', Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 35, pp.371-383.
Besley, Timothy and Ian Jewitt (1990),
`Optimal uniform taxation and the structure of consumer preferences', in G.D.Myles(ed), Measurement and modelling in
economics, Amsterdam:North-Holland.
Chaloupka, Frank (1991),
`Rational addictive behavior and cigarette smoking', Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 99, pp.722-743.
Corlett, W.J. and D.C. Hague (1953),
`Complementarity and the excess burden of taxation', Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 21, pp.21-30.
Deaton, Angus (1977),
`Equity,effciency, and the sturucture of indirect taxation', Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 8, pp.299-312.
Diamond, Peter A. and James A. Mirrlees (1973),
`Aggregate production with consumption externalities', Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 87, pp.1-24.
Dixit, Avinash K. (1990),
Optimization in Economic Theory, New York: Oxford University Press, 2nd ed.
Dockner, Engelbert J. and Gustav Feichtinger (1993),
`Cyclical consumption patterns and rational addiction', American Economic Review, Vol. 83, pp.256-263
Driskill, Robert and Stephen McCafferty (2000),
`Monopoly and oligopoly provision of addictive goods', International Economic Review, Vol. 42, pp. 43-68.
Goldbaum, David (2000),
`Life cycle consumption of a harmful and addiction goods', Economic Inquiry, Vol. 38, pp. 458-469.
Ebrahimi, Ahmad and Christopher Heady (1988),
`Tax design and household consumption', Economic Journal, Vol. 98, pp.83-96.
Grossman, Michael (1998),
`The demand for cocaine by young adults: A rational addiction approach',Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 17,pp.427-475.
Gruber, Jonathan and Botond koszegi (2002),
`A theory of government regulation of addiction bads:optimal tax levels and tax incidence for cigarette excise taxation', NBER Working Paper No.8777.
Head, J. G. (1966),
`On merit goods', Finanzarchiv, Vol. 25, pp.2-5.
Jou, Jyh-Bang (2001),
`Environment, Asset Characteristics, and optimal effluent fee', Environmental and Resource Economics, Vol. 20, pp.27-39.
Kenkel, Donald S. (1991),
`Health behavior, health knowledge, and schooling',Journal of Political Economics, Vol. 99, pp.287-305.
Kenkel, Donald S. ,Robert R. Reed and Ping Wang (2002),
`Rational addiction, peer externalities and long run effects of public policy', NBER Working Paper No.9249.
Labeaga, Jose M. (1999),
`A double-hurdle rational addiction model with heterogeneity: Estimating the demand for tobacco', Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 93, pp. 49-72.
Musgrave, Richard A. (1959),
The Theory of Public Finance, New York: Mcgrew-Hill Inc., p15.
Mirrlees, James (1976),
`Optimal tax theory: a synthesis',Journal of Public Economics, vol. 6, pp327-358.
Orphanides, Athanasios and David Zervos (1995),
`Rational addiction with learning and regret',Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 103, pp.739-759.
Pazner, Elisha A. (1975),
`Merit wants and the theory of taxation', Public Finance, Vol. 27, pp.460-472.
Ramsey, Frank (1927),
`A contribution to the theory of taxation', Economic Journal, Vol. 37, pp.47-61.
Suranovic, Steven M., Robert S. Goldfarb and Thomas C. Leonard (1999),`An economic theory of cigarette addiction', Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 18, pp.1-29.
Van, Cuong L. and Lisa Morhaim (2002),
`Optimal growth models with bounded or unbounded returns: a unifying approach', Journal of Economic Theory, Vol. 105,
pp.158-187.
Viscusi, W.Kip (1985),
`Are individuals Bayesian decision maker?', American Economic Review, Vol. 75, pp.381-385.
Viscusi, W.Kip (1990),
`Do smokers underestimate risks?', Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 98, pp.1253-1269.
Viscusi, W.Kip (1991),
`Age variations in risk perceptions and smoking decisions', Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 73, pp.577-588.
此全文未授權公開