跳到主要內容

簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 劉其昌
論文名稱: 通貨膨脹與租稅政策 :通貨膨脹稅之研究
指導教授: 林振國
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 社會科學學院 - 經濟學系
Department of Economics
論文出版年: 1978
畢業學年度: 67
語文別: 中文
論文頁數: 171
中文關鍵詞:
相關次數: 點閱:156下載:0
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 本文主要目的在探討政府經由增發貨幣,膨脹性融通(Inflationary Finance)支出,對持有貨幣餘額者課徵通貨膨脹稅(Inflation Tax)有關的問題。全文共分六章十九節,漸次闡明政府藉膨脹性融通課徵通貨膨脹稅的福利成本、最適條件(最適通貨膨脹率及邊際成本)、通貨膨脹稅的差異性租稅效果、租稅歸宿、以及通貨膨脹稅與工資所得稅的F.P. Ramsey最適租稅法則。茲就各章內容略述如下:第一章乃緒論:主要在說明本文的研究動機、研究範圍與方法,政府課征通貨膨脹稅的背景,及討論一般學者認為通貨膨脹稅對經濟發展的正反兩面意見而歸結於福利成本的高低乃衡量膨脹性融通優劣的標準;最後并對通貨膨脹稅的內容作一明確的定義。第二章為膨脹性融通的福利成本:共分四節係基於六個基本假設前提下,說明膨脹性融通的福利成本,首先比較M.J. Bailey以通貨膨脹率(π)與A. L. Marty以貨幣增發率(ρ)稅收(G)之比(亦即平均成本)來衡量膨脹性融通福利成本的方法,而引入E. Tower的邊際成本(dW/dG)概念。第三節中將貨幣視為一種商品,而通貨膨脹稅對貨幣餘額課稅即與一般選擇性銷售稅的性質相近,在獲得政府稅收相等的條件下,比較此兩種融通方式所加諸經濟社會福利損失的大小,而得知膨脹性融通的福利損失大於租稅融通的情況。第四節將前述基本假設逐步加以修正,以符合實際的情況,首先將銀行體系導入,即在法定準備率γ小於一,且銀行對活期存款支付利息的情況下,銀行體系創造貨幣的結果,將使政府增發貨幣的稅收利益外溢於銀行,以及當銀行以低於正常利率放款的借款者之間,因此政府為取得相同稅收所須的通貨膨脹率(稅率)必較高,并修正完全性預期的假設,而將時間因素導入,以動態觀點分析膨脹性融通的福利損失與膨脹稅收、及其現值的大小,而得出靜態經濟完全性預期、靜態經濟適應性預期、成長經濟完全性預期、成長經濟適應性預期,四種不同融通情況下,滿足邊際膨脹稅收現值增量等於邊際福利損失現值增量的均衡通貨膨脹率及其高低。第三章探討最適膨脹性融通、邊際成本及其比較:首先說明融通一項政府支出的最適條件將因情況而異。
    第二節中最適條件係滿足Adams Smith租稅原則的徵費節約原則,換言之在達成政府膨脹稅收極大的情況下,以變分學(Calculus)的尤拉等式(Euler Equation)求出前述四種不同融通情況下的最適通貨膨脹率及其邊際成本,并比較其大小。第三節中將指數化(Indexation)導入上項政府膨脹性融通的最適條件中,分析當政府府對持有名目貨幣餘額者按通貨膨脹率的一定比率θ指數調整貨幣購買力後對前節最適條件的影響,而獲知指數化將使膨脹性融通達成既定政府稅收的最適通貨膨脹率較指數化前為高。第四節就台灣民國35-38年實際資料,配以上述四種不同融通情況,估算當時膨脹性融通的最適通貨膨脹率π*(t),膨脹稅收現值(G*)、福利損失現值(W*)及福利損失現值與膨脹稅收現值兩者之比W*/G*詳如表(3-8)至(3-11)所示,而得出在π*(t)時W*/G*比以靜態經濟完全性預期膨脹性融通最高、靜態經濟適應性預期的情況次之、成長經濟適應性預期的情況再次之,而以成長經濟完全性預期的膨脹性融通W*/G*比最低。而最適通貨膨脹率π*(t)則以靜態經濟適應性預期情況最高,成長經濟適應性預期情況次之、靜態經濟完全性預期情況再次之,而以成長經濟完全性預期的最適通貨膨脹率最低。四章為通貨膨脹稅的差異性租稅效果及其歸宿:分五節,主要以J. Pithford與S.J. Turnovsky的物價工資模型中導入通貨膨脹稅(tπ),在維持政府實質總稅收固定不變的前提下,以差異性((Differential)租稅概念,分析通貨膨脹稅、工資所得稅、利潤稅與銷售稅間的替代關係對稅後利潤率、工資率以及租稅歸宿的影響。(但此時政府所課徵的通貨膨脹稅并非完全性預期的情況)。第五章說明通貨膨脹稅與工資所得稅的F.P. Ramsey最適租稅法則:
    F.P. Ramsey的最適租稅法則強調租稅課微應使消費者對所有商品的需求沿著受補償需求曲綫呈近似等比的降低,筆者仿照商品稅(Commodity Tax)的F.P. Ramsey最適租稅法則的求法,以差異性租稅概念,導出通貨膨脹稅與工資所得稅的Ramsey租稅法則,并由該一法則引伸出最適稅率應與課稅客體的彈性呈反比例的關係(亦即稅率應與彈性呈反比法則),因此當實質貨幣需求對通貨膨脹率缺乏彈性或彈性等於零時,對各目貨幣餘額課稅,係政府的—適當稅源。第六章為結論:針對前述五章的分析綜合整理出14.點結論。


    提要
    第一章 緒論1
    第一節 研究動機1
    第二節 研究目的與範圍2
    第三節 通貨膨脹稅的意義4
    第四節 本文結構5
    第二章 膨脹性融通福利成本的衡量9
    第一節 前言及基本假設9
    第二節 膨脹性融通福利成本之衡量11
    第三節 膨脹性融通與租稅融通福利成本的比較28
    第四節 假設之修正31
    第三章 最適膨脹性融通、邊際成本及其比較55
    第一節 前言
    第二節 最適條件58
    第三節 指數化對最適條件的影響與比較66
    第四節 實際資料試析75
    第四章 通貨膨脹稅的差異性租稅效果及其歸宿93
    第一節 模型93
    第二節 工資所得稅、利潤稅、銷售稅的差異性租稅效果與非差異性租稅效果的比較98第三節 導入通貨膨脹稅後差異性租稅效果衡量104
    第四節 差異租稅歸宿115
    第五節 比較122
    第五章 通貨膨脹稅與工資所得稅的F.P. Ramsey最適租稅法則152
    第一節 前言152
    第二節 F.P. Ramsey最適租稅法則153
    第六章 結論166
    參考書目172

    (1)林鐘雄:弗利曼貨幣理論與政策之研究,台北,三民書局民國60年4月,p.68.
    (2)陳丕汎:「通貨膨脹政策的福利損失與經濟成長」,現代經濟金融月刊,第二卷第九期,民國61年9月,pp.19-21.
    (3) Aghevli, B.B., and M.S. Khan, ”Inflationary Finance and the Dynamics of Inflation, : Indonesia 1951-72, The American Economic Review , Vo 1.67, No. 3, (June, 1977) pp.400-401.
    (4) Auernheimer, L. ,“The Honest Government’s Guide to The Revenue from the Creation of Money”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 82, No.3, (May/June, 1974), P.598-606.
    (5) Auld, D.A.L., ,“Taxation and Inflation: A Survey of Recent Theory and Empirical Evidence,” Public Finance Quarterly, Vol.5, No.4,(oct.1977)pp.406-418.
    (6) Bailey, M.J., ”The Welfare Cost of Inflationary Finance ” The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. LXIV, No.2, (April, 1956), pp.100-106.
    (7) Barro, R.J., “Inflationary Finance and The Welfare Cost of Inflation,” The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.80, No.5(Sept./oct,1972), p.982-989.
    (8) Baumol, W.J., and D.F. Brandford, “Optimal Departures from Marginal Cost Pricing,” The American Economic Review, Vol. LX, No.3, (June,1970),pp.265-283.
    (9) Brennan, H.G. and D.A.L. Auld, “The Tax-Cut as An Anti-Inflationary Devices,” Economic Record, Vol. XLIV, No.108, (Dec. ,1968), p.520-25.
    (10) Buchanan, J.M., The Public Finance, Third Edition, (Illinois: Richard D. Irwin Inc.1970), Chapter26.p.297.
    (11) Cagan, p. ”The Channels of Monetary Effects on Interest Rates, (New York: National Bureau of Economic Research 1970), Chapter2, pp.9-14.
    (12) Cathcart C.D. ”Monetary Dynamics, Growth and the Efficiency of Inflationary Finance, ” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 6, No.2,(May,1974), pp.169-190.
    (13) Dasgupta, P. and J.E. Stiglitz, “On Optimal Taxation and Public Production,” The Review of Economic Studies, Vol. XXXIX(1) ,No. 117, (Jan., 1972), pp.87-103.
    (14) Diamond, P.A., “Inflation and The Comprehensive Tax Base,” The Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 4, No.3, (August, 1975) ,pp.227-232.
    (15) _______,“A Many Person Ramsey Tax Rule,” Journal of Public Economics VoI.4,No.4,(NOV. ,1975),pp.335-42.
    (16) Farioletti, M, “Tax Administration Funding and Fiscal Policy,” National Tax Journal Vol. XXVI, No.1, (March ,1973) ,pp. 1-15.
    (17) Foley, D.K. and M. Sidrauski, Monetary and Fiscal Policy in A Growing Economy, (London: The Macmillan Company,1971), Chapter 12,p.188.
    (18) Friedman, M., ”The Monetary Dynamics of Hyper-In-flation,” Studies in The Quantity Theory of Money, (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1956) Chapter II, pp.77-91
    (19) _______, Dollars and Deficit, (New Jersey: Englewood Cliffs Prentice-Hall Inc. ,1968), Chapter Chapter 3.
    (20) _______, Government Revenue from Inflation”, The Journal of Political Economy Vol. 79, No.4, (July/Aug., 1971), pp.846-850.
    (21) Gordon, R. J., “The Demand for and Supply of Inflation”, The Journal of law and Economics, Vol, XVIII, No.3, (Dec. 1975), pp.807-816.
    (22) Grieson, R. E., “On the Optimal level of Taxation, Borrowing and Government Expenditures”, National Tax Journal, Vol, XXVIII, No.2 (June, 1975), pp. 251-52.
    (23) Intriligator, M. D., Mathematical Optimization and Economic Theory,台北美亞圖書公司,民國66年9月二版pp.308-11.
    (24) Johnson, H. G., Essays in Monetary Economics, ( Harvard University Press, 1967), Chapter III, pp. 122-26.
    (25) _______, Macroeconomics and Monetary Theory, (Chicago: Illinois Adline Publishing Company, 1972), First Edition, Chapter 18, pp.151-54.
    (26) _______, “A Note On The Dishonest Government and The Inflation Tax”, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol.3, No.3, (July, 1977), pp.375-77.
    (27) Julio, H. G., “On Structural Inflation and Latin- American Structuralism”, Oxford Economic Papers, Vol. 16, No.3, (Nov., 1964), pp.321-32.
    (28) Lioi, V. C., Inflation in Developing Countries, (New York: American Elsevier Publishing Company, Inc., 1974), p.112.
    (29) Marty, A. L., “Growth and The Welfare Cost of Inflationary Finance”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.75, No.1, (Feb., 1967), pp.71-76.
    (30) _______, “Growth, Satiety, and The Tax Revenue from Money Creation”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 81, No.5, (See/Oct., 1973), p.1140.
    (31) _______, “A Note On the Welfare Cost of Money Creation”, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol.2, No.1, (Jan. 1976), pp.121-24.
    (32) Mcculloch, J. H., Money and Inflation, ( New York: Academic Press Inc., 1975) Chapter 7, pp. 101-02.
    (33) Meier, G. M., “Leading Issues in Economic Development”, Third Edition, (Stanford University, 1976), Part, V, pp.314-15.
    (34) Mirrlees, J. A., “Optimal Commodity Taxation in a Two-Class Economy”, Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 4, No.1, (Feb., 1975), pp.27-33.
    (35) Mundell, R. A., “Growth, Stability and Inflationary Finance”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. LXXIII, No.2, (April, 1965), pp.97-108.
    (36) Mussa, M., “The Welfare Cost of Inflation and the Role of Money as a Unit of Account”, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. IX, No.2, (May, 1977), pp.279-84.
    (37) Newlyn, W. T., “The Inflation Tax In Developing Countries”, Journal of Development Studies, Vol. 13, No.2, (Jan. 1977), pp.8-21.
    (38) Nichols, D. A., “Seine Principles of Inflationary Finance”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 82,No.2, (March/April, 1974), pp.423-30.
    (39) Page, S. A. B. and S. Trollope, “An International Survey of Indexing and Its Effects”, National Institute Economic Review, No.70, (Nov., 1974), p.46.
    (40) Parkin, M. and G. Zis, “Inflationary Expectations and Some Dynamic Aspects of the Welfare Cost”, Inflation in the World Economy, (Manchester University Press, 1976), pp.47-66.
    (41) _______, “Why Stable Inflations Fail : an Essay in Political Economy”, Inflation in the World Economy, (Manchester University Press, 1976), pp.73-85.
    (42) Peacock A. T. and J. Williamson, “Consumption Taxes and Compensatory Finance”, Economic Journal, Vol. LXXVII, No.305, (March, 1967), pp.27-45.
    (43) Phelps, E. S., “Inflation In The Theory of Public Finance”, The Swedish Journal of Economics , VoI. 75, No.1, (1973), p.68.
    (44) _______, “Anticipated Inflation and Economic Welfare”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. LXXIII, No.1, (Feb., 1965), pp.1-17.
    (45) Pigou, A. C., A Study In Public Finance, (London: Macmillan & Co. LTD., 1962), Chapter IX, p.104.
    (46) Pithford, J. and S. J. Turnovaky, “Income Distribution and Taxes In an Inflationary Context”, Economica, Vol. 42, No.167, (Aug., 1975), pp.272-76.
    (47) Ramsey, F. P., “A Contribution to the Theory of Taxation”, The Economic Journal, Vol. XXXVII, No.145, (March, 1927), pp.47-60.
    (48) Roberto, F. Jr., “Indexation : Optimality Conditions for Revenue from Inflation and Social Gain”, Explorations in Economic Research, Vol. 4, No.1, (Winter, 1977), pp.93-100.
    (49) Robinson, E. A. G., Problem in Economic Development, (New York: S. T. Martin’s Press, 1966), pp.212-27.
    (50) Sandmo, A., “Optimal Taxation-An Introduction to the literature”, The Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 6, No.1.2, (July-August, 1976), pp.37-38,, pp.49-50.
    (51) Shoup, C. S., Public Finance, (Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company, 1970), Chapter 18, pp.454-57.
    (52) Simpson, T. D., Money, Banking and Economic Analysis , (New Jersey: Englewood Cliffs, Prentice Hall Inc., 1976), Chapter 13, pp.253-56., Chapter 14, pp.276-81.
    (53) Tatom, J. A., “The Welfare Cost of Inflation”, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, Vol. 58, No.11, (Nov., 1976), p.14.
    (54) Thirlwall, A. P., Inflation, Saving and Growth in Developing Countries, (New York : S.T. Martin’s Press LTD. 1974), Chapter 1, p.15, Chapter 2, pp.18.36.
    (55) _______, Financing Economic Development, (London: The Macmillan Press, LTD., 1976), Chapter 2, pp.29-40.
    (56) Tower E., “More On the Welfare Cost of Inflationary Finance”, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, Vol, 3, No.4, (Nov., 1971), p.850.
    (57) Turvey, R., “Inflation As a Tax in World War II”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 69, No.1, (Feb., 1961), pp.70-73.
    (58) Wildasin, D. E., “Distributional neutrality and Optimal Commodity Taxation”, The American Economic Review, Vol. 67, No. 5, (Dec. 1977), pp.889-893.

    無法下載圖示 (限達賢圖書館四樓資訊教室A單機使用)
    QR CODE
    :::