| 研究生: |
劉斐青 Liu, Fei Ching |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
國際法上漁業資源養護管理制度之研究 ---兼論一九八九年中美漁業糾紛 A Study of the Conservation And Management of the Fisheries Resources in International Law --- Case Study of 1989 Sino-U.S. Fishery Disputes |
| 指導教授: |
王人傑
Wang, Jen chieh |
| 學位類別: |
碩士
Master |
| 系所名稱: |
國際事務學院 - 外交學系 Department of Diplomacy |
| 論文出版年: | 1993 |
| 畢業學年度: | 81 |
| 語文別: | 中文 |
| 論文頁數: | 156 |
| 中文關鍵詞: | 漁業資源 |
| 外文關鍵詞: | Fishery Resources |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:184 下載:0 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
海洋約占地球表面積的三分之二強 , 自古以來人類的生活就與海洋有著
密不可分的關係 , 尤其是二十世紀以來 , 海洋對人類的重要性益發突
顯 , 因為工業的進步以及人口的激增 , 使得在原料匱乏及陸地食物不足
的情況下 , 更彰顯出人類有朝向海洋發展的必要性與迫切性.海洋資源可
分為有生資源和無生資源 , 而有生資源即是指漁業資源 . 傳統的觀念認
為漁資源是"取之不盡 , 用之不竭" 再加上行之已久的 "海洋自由" 原
則之概念, 因此自來人們對漁資源的獲取就沒有多大的限制 . 但是晚近
以來 , 漁獲需求的增加以及科技的進步 ,使得人類開發採捕漁資源的活
動大大增加 . 在沒有規範限制的情況下,過度漁捕和不正當漁捕使得漁資
源有枯竭之虞 , 此即造成了"公有物的悲劇" . 因此本文先檢視現行國際
法中漁業資源的養護管理制度, 另外由於我國和美國之間的漁業糾紛多年
來一直無法獲得完滿的解決 ,一九八九年更因為公海捕鮭及流刺網漁捕問
題 ,雙方簽署了 "北太平洋公海流網換函" , 其中多項條款備受國人爭
議 , 曾經引起喧然大波 , 故本文並兼論一九八九年中美漁業糾紛 ,再檢
視目前國際間對鮭魚的養護管理之實踐 , 期能了解國際間養護管理該漁
種之趨勢 , 俾日後我國在處理類似事件時有所依循.文分六章 . 第壹章
為導論 ,第二章先概述養護管理漁資源的目標方法及重要的分配問題, 第
三章詳述歷屆海洋法會議對漁資源養護管理的規範 , 而其中以第三屆海
洋法會議的規範最為詳實 . 第四章探討中美之間的漁業糾紛 ,並評析一
九八九年雙方漁業協定中的可議之處 .第五章檢視北太平洋及大西洋鮭魚
的養護管理 ,以明瞭區域合作之實踐趨勢 .第六章為結論 .
第一章 導 論………………………………………………………………… 1
第一節 研究動機及目的………………………………………………… 1
第二節 研究範圍及限制………………………………………………… 4
第三節 研究方法及架構………………………………………………… 6
第二章 漁業資源養護管理之概念………………………………………… 10
第一節 養護觀念的形成背景………………………………………… 12
第二節 養護管理的目標、機制與方法……………………………… 18
第三節 養護管理與分配問題………………………………………… 28
第三章 歷屆海洋法會議與漁資源的養護管理…………………………… 42
第一節 第一、二屆海洋法會議與養護管理………………………… 42
第二節 第三屆海洋法會議與養護管理……………………………… 51
第四章 評析一九八九年中美漁業糾紛…………………………………… 72
第一節 中美漁業糾紛之背景簡介…………………………………… 72
第二節 論述一九八九年中美漁業協定……………………………… 81
第五章 養護管理鮭魚之國際實踐………………………………………… 94
第一節 北太平洋鮭魚的國際實踐…………………………………… 95
第二節 大西洋鮭魚的國際實踐…………………………………… 113
第六章 結 論…………………………………………………………… 129
參考書目 ………………………………………………………………… 135
附 錄 ………………………………………………………………… 145
主要參考書目
一、 書籍
周子應,楊志雄編著,海洋法知識,上海:知識出版社,1985。
丘宏達編輯,現代國際法基本文件,台北:三民書局,民國七十五年九月版。
黃 異著,國際法上船舶國籍制度之研究,台北:文笙書局,民國七十四年六月版。
陳治世著,學生國際法,台北:漢苑出版社,民國六十八年九月版。
張永恆編著,國際法院訴訟案與諮詢意見案,台北:正中書局,民國六十六年版。
傅崑成著,國際海洋法與漁權之爭,台北,三民書局,民國七十九年八月版。
Anand, R. P. , Law of The Sea Caracas And Beyond , New
Delhi: Radoamt Publishers, 1980.
Attard, David Joseph, The Exclusive Economic Zone III Internationa
1 La w , Oxford : CIa rendon Press , 1987.
Bouchez, L. J. and L. Ka ij en , The Future of The La w of The
Sea, The Hauge: Martinus Nijhoff, 1973.
Booth, Ken , La w , Force & Diplomacy a t Sea London George
Allen & Unwin , 1985.
Dahmani, M. , The Fisheries Regime of The Exclusive Economic
Zone, Netherlands : Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1987.
Dyke, Jon M. Van , Consensus And Confrontation : The United States and The Law of The Sea Institute, 1985.
Eckert, Ross D., The Enclosure of Ocean Resource, Hoover Institution Press, 1979.
Extavour, Winston Conrad, The Exclusive Economic Zone, Geneve: Institut Universitaire De Hautes Etudes Internationales, 2nd, 1981.
Johnston, Douglas M., The Internatioanl Law of Fisheries: A Framework For Policy-Oriented Inquiries, New Haven: New Haven Press, 1987.
Knight, H. Gray, The Law of The Sea: Cases, Document And Reading , Baton Rouge: Claitor’s Law Books & Publishing Devision, 1978.
Knight, H. Gary, Managing The Sea’s Living Resources, NY.: Lexington Books, 1977.
Koers, Albert W., International Regulation of Marine Fisheries, Lodon: Fishing News, 1973.
Laursen, Finn (ed), Toward A New International Marine Order, The Hague:Martinus Nijhoff Publisher, 1982.
Lumb, R.D. , The Law of The Sea And Australian Off-Shore Area, Queensland: University of Queensland Press, 1978.
O’connell, D.P. , The International Law of The Sea, Vol.I, II, NY: Oxford Univ. Press, 1984.
Oda, Shigeru, The Law of The Sea In Our Time – I , New Development, 1966-1975, Leyden: Sijthoff, 1977.
Oda, Shigeru, The Internaqtional Law of The Ocean Development, N.V.: Sijthoff International Publishing Co., 1972.
Oda, Shigeru, International Law of The Resources of The Sea, Netherlands : Sijthoff & Noordhoff, 1979.
Oxman, Bernard H., David D. Caron, Charles L.O.Buderi, Law of The Sea --- U.S. Policy Dilemma, San Francisco: ICS Press, 1983.
Pilarski, Kim, International Law, Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1990
Russett, Bruce & Hawey Starr, World Politics : The menu for choice, W.H.: Freeman and Company, 3 rd ed. , 1989.
二、 論文期刊
宋燕輝,一九八九年中美有關北太平洋公海漁捕互動之分析,中美關係報告,中央研究院美國文化研究所,民國八十年六月。
林享能,從國際法觀點“中美北太平洋公海流刺網捕魚協定”,問題與研究第二十九卷第一期,民國七十八年十月。
陳超雄,中美漁業糾紛探索,美國月刊,第四卷第九期,民國七十九年一月。
蘇義雄,漁業資源之開發與海洋法,中興法學十八期,民國七十一年。
張麟徵,從國際法看中美漁業協議,立法院“中美漁業協定”前途聽證會會議資料,民國七十八年九月。
石柏士,國際法上養護與管理---漁業資源問題之研究,政治大學外交所碩士論文,民國七十三年。
張薰雅,北太平洋鮭魚公海捕撈問題之探討,海洋大學海研所碩士論文,民國八十年。
楊敏華,國際海洋法---經濟海域與漁業資源之研究,海洋學院海研所碩士論文,民國七十四年。
謝寶容,國際漁業管理制度之研究---兼論海洋法之發展及我國漁業政策之取向,海洋大學海研所碩士論文,民國七十六年。
Alexender, Lewis M. & Regional Arrangements in The Oceans, American Journal of International Law, Vol.71, 1977.
Aleexender, Lewis M. & Robert D. Hodgson, The Role of The Geographically – Disadvantaged States in The Law of The Sea, San Diego Law Review, Vol.13, No.3 , 1976.
Allot, Philip, Making the New International Law: Law of The Sea as Law of The Future, International Journal , XL, Summer, 1985.
Arnand, R.P., The Politics of a New Legal Order for Fisheries, Ocean Development and International Law Journal, Vol.11, No.3/4,1982.
Bishop, William W., The 1958 Geneva Convention of Fishing and Conser-vation of The Living Resources of The High Seas,Columbia Law Review, Vol.62, 1962.
Bubier, Jill L. , International Management of Atlantic Salmon, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.19, 1988.
Burke, William T. , Anadromous Species and The New International Law of The Sea, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.22, 1991.
Byrne, John V. Salmon is King –Or Is It? Environmental Law, Vol.16, 1986.
Cicin-Sain, Biliana & Robert W. Knecht, The Problem of Governance of U.S. Ocean Resources and the New Exclusive Economic Zone, Ocean Development and International Law Journal , Vol. 15, No.3/4, 1985.
Clingan , Thomas A. Jr., A Sencond Look at United States Fisheries Management, San Diego Law Review, Vol.9 , No.3, 1972.
D’amato, Anthony & Sudhir K. Chopra, Whales: Their Emerging Right To Life, The American Journal of International Law, Vol.85, 1991.
Feldman, Mark B. & David Colson, The Maritime Boundaries of the United States, The American Society of International Law, Vol. 75, 1981.
Futzoatruck ,John, Fishing Technology , Chicago Law Review, 1989.
Fishery Conservation and Management Act of 1976, Public Law 94-265, The American Journal of International Law, Vol.70, 1976.
Hsieh, Mark Mon-Chang, The 1989 U.S –Republic of China Fisheries Negotiations, Contemporary Asia Studies Series, 1991.
Jacobson, Jon L. , International Fisheries Law In The Year 2010. Louisiana Law Review, Vol.45, 1985.
Jensen, Thomas C., The United States – Canada Pacific Salmon Inter-ception Treaty : An Historical and Legal Overview, Enviornment Law, Vol. 16, 1986.
Johnston, Douglas M. , The Driflnetting Problem in The Pacific
Ocean : Legal Considerations and Diplomatic Options
Ocean Develop-ment and International Law, Vol. 21 , 1990.
Johnston, Douglas M. , Is Coastal State Fishery Management
Successful or Not? , Ocea n Development And Interna tional
La w , Vol. 2 2 1 9 9 1.
Kiss, Alexandre , The Common Heritage of Mankind : Utopia Or
Reality? International Journal, XI , Summer, 1985.
Kwia tkowsks, Barbara , Creeping Jurisdiction Beyond 200 Miles 111
The Light of The 1982 La w of The Sea Convention and
Sta te Practice, Ocea n Development and Interna tiona 1 La w ,
Vol. 22, 1991.
Lee, Luke T. , The La w of The Sea Convention And Third Sta tes
, The America n Journal of Interna tiona I La w , Vol. 77 ,1983.
Larson, David L. , When Will The U.N. Convention on The Law of
The Sea Come Into Effect? , Ocean Development and
International Law, Vol. 20 , 1989.
Lyman, Henry. Lox et Lex, Ocean Development and International
Law, Vo1.15, No.1, 1985.
McHgug ,J .L. , Fisheries Management Under The Manguson Act:
Is • It Working? , Ocean Development and International
Law , Vol. 21 1990
Miller, Marc L. & Charles F. Broches, U.S. Fishery Negotiations with Canada and Mexico, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol. 14, 1985.
Mirvahabi, Farin, Conservation and Management of Fisheries in The Exclusive Economic Zone , Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce Vol.9, No.2, 1978.
Miller, Morton M. & Panl J. Hooker, & Peter H. Fricke, Impressions of Ocean Fisheries Management Under the Magnuson Act, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.21, 1990.
Moore,Gerald, National Legisiation For The Management of Fisheries Under Extended Coastal State Jurisdiction , Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce, Vol.11, No.2 , 1980.
Oda, Shigeru, Fisheries Under The United Nations Convention on The Law of The Sea, The American Journal of International Law, Vol.77, 1983.
Pearse, Peter H. From Open Access to Private Property: Recent Innovations in Fishing Rights as Instruments of Fisheries Policy. Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.23, 1992.
Pollnac, Richard B. & Susan Jacke Littlefield Sociocultural Aspects of Fisheries Management , Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.12, No.3/4, 1983.
Poutecorvo , Giulio, Fishery Statistics : What We Need to Know, Ocean Development and International LAW, Vol.15, No. 3/4, 1985.
Saguirian, Artemy A., Russia and Some Pending Law of the Sea Issues in the North Pacific : Controversies over Higher Sea’s Fisheries Regulation and Delimitation of Marine Spaces, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol. 23, 1992.
Saguirian, Artemy A., Russia and Some Pending Law of the Sea Issues in the North Pacific : Controversies over Higher Sea’s Fisheries Regulation and Delimitaiton of Marine Spaces, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol. 23 , 1992.
Sathre, Constance, Salmon Interception on The High Sea : A Countinuing Controversy Between the United States and Japan, Environment Law, Vol. 16, 1986.
Silva, Maynard, The Law of The Sea and The U.S. Exclusive Economic Zone: Perspectives on Marine Transporation and Fisheries, Ocean Development and International LAW, Vol. 15, No. 3/4, 1985
Sinjela, A. Mpazi, Landlock States Rights In The Exclusive Economic Zone From The Perspective of The U.N. Convention on The Law of The Sea: An Historical Evaluation, Ocean Development and International Law, Vol.20, 1989.
Twitchell, Marlyn, Implementing The U.S. – Canada Pacific Salmon Treaty: The Struggle to Move From “ Fish War” to Cooperative Fishery Management ,Ocean Development
and International Law, Vol. 20 1989.
Vicuna, F. Orrego , Interna tiona I Coopera tion In Sa imon Fisheries
and A Comparative Law Perspective on Salmon and Ocean
Ranching Industry, Ocean Development and International
La w , V 0 I. 2 2 , 1 9 9 l.
Yanagida, Joy A. , The Pacific Salmon Treaty, The American
Journal of International Law, Vol. 81 , 1987.
Young, Ora 11 R. , The PoJitica 1 Economy of Fish : The Fishery
Conservation and Management Act of 1976 , Ocean Development
and International Law, Vol. 10 , No. 3/4 , 1982
(限達賢圖書館四樓資訊教室A單機使用)