| 研究生: |
葉美華 Ye, Mei Hua |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
照顧者與酬金方案:女性主義觀點 |
| 指導教授: |
劉梅君
Liu, Mei Jun |
| 學位類別: |
碩士
Master |
| 系所名稱: |
社會科學學院 - 社會學系 Department of Sociology |
| 論文出版年: | 1996 |
| 畢業學年度: | 84 |
| 語文別: | 中文 |
| 論文頁數: | 116 |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:189 下載:0 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
第一章緒論..........1
第一節研究動機..........1
第二節研究範圍與目的..........2
一、研究範圍..........2
二、研究目的..........5
第三節研究方法..........6
第二章女性與照顧..........11
第一節照顧者女性化..........11
一、實證發現..........11
二、心理與社會因素的解釋..........12
三、女性主義之解釋..........19
第二節照顧的概念與負荷..........22
一、照顧的概念..........22
二、照顧的負荷..........24
三、照顧的需求與支持..........26
第三節照顧與貧窮..........29
一、男/女、公/私、有酬/無酬二分的領域..........29
二、社會安全制度..........31
第四節照顧者的權利..........33
一、公民權、政治權與社會權的概念..........34
二、照顧者與公民權..........35
第三章照顧者財務支持相關方案介紹與檢視..........38
第一節概述..........38
一、定義與範圍..........38
二、家屬照顧津貼的發展..........39
三、方案類型..........40
第二節三國制度介紹..........45
一、英國..........45
二、美國..........48
三、芬蘭..........51
第三節社會政策中之照顧者..........54
一、非正式照顧的四種型態..........54
二、照顧者型態與政策之對應..........57
第四節酬金方案之爭議..........61
第四章付費式家屬照顧政策之討論..........64
第一節現有方案..........64
一、評估..........64
二、對照顧關係的影響..........69
三、困境..........70
第二節經濟支持-女性主義模式..........72
一、目標..........72
二、內容..........73
第五章台灣照顧政策..........78
第一節台灣長期照顧現況..........78
一、照顧問題的嚴重..........78
二、女性的無償照顧..........79
三、被國家政策忽略的照顧者..........81
第二節付費式家屬照顧..........83
一、財政問題..........83
二、家庭道德的考量..........84
第三節照顧者政策之建議..........85
第六章結論與討論..........88
第一節研究發現與研究意義..........88
一、研究發現..........88
二、研究意義..........90
三、研究限制..........91
第二節討論..........91
第三節結語..........93
參考書目..........94
附錄一允許付費式家屬照顧地區:資格,給付型態,行政限制..........105
附錄二不允許付費式家屬照顧的地區與原因..........106
一、中文書目
伊慶春(1 988) <中國女性的婚姻與職業>文崇一、蕭新煌主編 中國
人;觀念與行為台北:巨流圖書。
呂寶靜(1 993)性別與社會福利,<社會福利基本理念研習營參考資料
>,台北:中華民國現代社會福利協會。
呂寶靜,陳景寧(1996) <女性家屬照顧者之處境與福利建構>。「女
性﹒囡家﹒照顧工作」研討會,女學會。
林萬億(1 994) <福利國家:歷史比較的分析>台北:巨流圖書公司
(1993) <公平正義的福利利國一民主進步黨的社會福利政策>
台北:民主進步黨中央黨部
周月清(1 996) <殘障照顧與女性公民身份> 。「 女性﹒國家﹒照顧工
作」研討會,女學會。
吳慧婷(1994) <台北市殘障居家生活禍助對成年智障者家庭影響之研
究>東吳社會工作研究所士論文。
俞智敏、陳光達、陳素梅、張君玫譯《女性主義觀點的社會學〉台北:
巨流。原著Abbott. P & Wallace. C ‘An lntroduction to
Sociology Feminist Perspectives' , Routledge
胡幼慧(1 996) <解讀台灣長期照護體系的神話r 家」與「國」的性
方'J 剖析與另類思考> 。「 女性﹒國家﹒照顧工作」研討會,女學
會。
(1 995) <男主外,女主內?一婦女與工作> 。「 婦女研究十年一
婦女人權的回顧與展望」研討會,台灣大學人口研究中心婦女研
究室。
唐文慧、王宏仁(1 993) (社會福利理論一流派與爭議〉台北:巨流圖書
莫黎黎譯(1993) <老年痴呆病患照顧者的支持性團體> Wasow, M.
著,社區發展季刊, 62, 83.88
黃金鳳譯(1 993) <家屬照顧酬金方案一消費者觀點之探討>社區發
展季刊, 62, 43-49
陳鳳至(1 993) <台灣地區女性勞工福利之研究一從女性主義觀點的考
察>,中正大學勞工研究所碩士論文。
湯鹿玉(199 1)<痴呆症老人照顧者的負荷及其相關因素之探討>,台灣
大學護理學研究所碩士論文。
侍立葉(1995) <建構女人福利國>。劉毓秀主編,台灣婦女處境白皮
書1995 年pp.7-36 ,時報出版。
楊佩琪(1990) < 老人癡呆病患家屬壓力與需求探討>。東海社工研究
所碩士論文。
詹火生(1992) (台灣地區老人安養服務之研究〉行政院研考會。
劉毓秀主編(1995) (台灣婦女處境白皮書1995 年〉時報出版。
(1 996) <女性、國家、公民身份:歐美模式、斯堪地那維亞模式
與台灣現況的比較思考> 。「 女性﹒國家-照顧工作」研討會
女學會。
蔡碧藍(1995) <出院憂鬱症病患照顧者之負荷及其相關因素之探討
>,台灣大學醫學院護理學研究所碩士論文。
蔡玉霞(1 995) <住院心臟衰竭病患照顧者的負荷及其相關因素之探討
>,國防醫學院護理研究所碩士論文。
劉梅君(1 996) <建構「性別敏感」的公民權:從女性照顧工作本質之
探討出發> 。「 女性﹒國家﹒照顧工作」研討會,女學會。
謝美娥(1 993) (老人長期照護的相關論題〉台北:桂冠
二、英文書目
Abel, E.K.(1989) 'The Ambiguities of Social Support: Adult Daughters
Caring for Frail Elderly Parents' Journal of Aging Studies. 3(3) Fall,
211-230.
Ansello, E.F., and Eustis, N.N. (1992) 'Aging and Disabilities: Seeking
Common Ground. Generations, 16(1).
Aronson, 1. (1992) ,Women's Sense of Responsibility for the Care of Old
People: "But Who Else Is Going to Do It?'" Gender and Society Vo1.6
No.1 pp. 8-29
Baldock, J. and C. Ungerson(1991) "'What d'ya want if you don't want
money?" a feminist critique of "paid Volunteering"', in Maclean M.
and Groves, D. (eds) Women's Issues in Social Policy. Routledge,
London and New York.
Biegel, D.E.(1993) (BOOK REVIEW) 'Wages for caring:Compensating
Family Care of The Elderly'.in Nathan L. Linsk et al,England. New
YorkPraeger, 1992.
Calasanti,T.M. & Bailey,C.A.(1991) 'Gender Inequality and the Division of
Household Labor in the United States and Sweden: A Socialist Feminist
Approach' Social Problems. 38(1) Feb. pp. 34-53.
Callender, C. (1987) 'Redundancy, Unemployment and Povelty' in
Glendinning, C. and Millar, J. (eds) "Women and Poverty in Britain"
pp.13 7-158.
Chappell, N.L.(1990) 'Aging and Social Care' in Binstock, H.H. and L.K.
George (eds) Handbook of Aging and Social Sciences. San Diego,
California: Academic Press, Inc.
Craig, G & C.Glendinning(1993) 'Rationing versus choice: Tensions and
options. Cash and care for disabled and older people and their carers' in
Deakin, N. & Page, R.(eds) The Costs of Welfare. Avebury. Aldershot.
Chap. 9. pp. 165-182.
Cutler,B.(1989) The Swedish Example American Demographics 1989
Apr.pp. 70
Dalley,G.(1988)' Ideologies of Caring: Rethinking Community and
Collectivism' Contemporruy Sociology 18(6) Nov. 953-954.
Dvvyer,J.M. & Seccombe,K.(1991) 'Elder Care as Family Labor: The
Inf1uence of Gendr and Family Position' Journal of Family Issues 12(2),
June, 229-247.
England, S., Linsk, N.L., Simon-Rusinowitz, L., & Keigher, S.M. (1989)
'Paid family caregiving and the market view of home care: Agency
perspectives' J oumal of Health and Social Policy, 1 (2), 31-53.
(1990) 'Paying kin for care: Agency barriers to formalizing informal
care' Journal of Aging & Social Policy, 2(2), 63-86.
Esping-Andersen, G.(1990) 'The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism'
Polity Press, Cambridge.
Evers, A., M. PijI and C. Ungerson (eds)(1994) 'Payments for Care: A
Comparative Overview'. Aldershot: Avebw)'.
Evers, A.(1994) 'Payments for Care: A Small but Significant Part of a
Wider Debate' in Evers, A. et al. pp. 19-41.
Finley,N.1.(1989) 'Theories of Family Labor as Applied to Gender
Differences in Caregiving for Elderly Parents' Journal of Marriage and
the Family. Sl(1) Feb. 79-86.
Gerald, L.B.(1993) 'Paid Family Caregiving: A Review of Progress and
Policies' Journal of Aging & Social Policy vol.5, No. 112 , pp.73-89.
Gerstel,N. & Gallagher,S. (1994) , Caring for Kith and Kin: Gender,
Employment, and the Privatization of Care' Social Problems; 41 (4),
Nov. S19-S39.
Glendinning C. (1990) 'Dependency and Interdependency:the Income of
InfOlmal Carers and the Impact of Social Security'. JOW11al of Social
Policy 19, Oct pp.469-497.
Glendinning, C. and E. Mclaughlin(1993) 'Paying for informal care: lessons
form Finland' Journal of European Social Policy, 3:4, 239-S3.
Glendinning, C and 1. Millar(1989)'Poverty: the forgotten Englishwoman.
Reconstructing research and policy on poverty' in
Graham H.(1983) 'Caring:A Labour of Love' in 1.Finch & D.Groves(eds)A
Labow· of Love:Women, Work and Caring. Chap. 1, pp.13-30. London:
routeledge & Kegan Paul.
(1991) 'The Concept of Caring in Feminist Research:The Case of
Domestic Service' Sociology.Vol.2S No.1 Feb.pp. 61-78
(1987) 'Women's Povelty and Caring',ch.l1in Glendining, C. &
100
Millar, leeds) Women and Poverty in Britain
Grana, J. M.(1983) 'Disability Allowances for Long-tenn Care in Western
Europe and the United States' International Social Secwity Review
36(2): 207-21
Guberman(1988) , The Family, Women and Caring: Who Cares for the
Carers?' Resources for Feminist Research 17(2),June, 37-40.
Hooyman, N., lGonyea(1995) 'Feminist Perspectives on Family Care Policies
for Gender Justice' Sage.
Horl, J.(1993) Eldercare Policy Between the State and Family:
Austria, Journal of Aging & Social Policy, 5, 1-2, 1993, pp.155-168 0
Iris Marion Yotll1g(1995) Mothers, Citizenship, and Independence: A
Critique of Pure Family Values Ethics 105 pp.535-556
Joshi, H. (1987) 'The Cost of Caring' in Glendinning, C. & 1. Millar(eds)
Women and Poverty in Britain. Wheatsheaf Books.
Kahana, E., D.E. Biegel and M.L. Wykle 'Family Cargiving Across the
Lifespan'Family Caregiver Applications Series VA .Sage.
Keigher, S.M. (1991) 'Wages or Welfare? Compensating caregiving in two
conservative social welfare states' Journal of Aging & Social Policy,
3(3), 83-104. '
Keigher, S.M. & Murphy, C. (1992) , A Consumber View of a Family Care
Compensation Program for the Elderly' Social Service Review, June,
256-277.
Keigher, S.M. and R.I. Stone(1994) 'Payments for Care: The Case of the
United States of America' in Evers, A. et al. pp.321-345.
Land, H.(1991) 'Time to care' in Maclean,M. and Groves, D. (eds) ,Women
issues in Social Policy. pp. 7-19 New York: Routledge.Ruth Lister
(1990) 'Women, Economic Dependency and Citizenship'. Journal of
Social Pohcy 1990, 19,4,Oct pp.445-467.
Leat, D. and C. Unger son (1994) 'Payments for Care: The Case of Britain' ,
in Evers et al., pp.261-24
Leira, A.(1993) 'Mothers, Markets and the State: A Scandinavian "Model"',
Journal of Social Policy,22,3,329-347
(1994) 'Concepts of Caring: Loving, Thinking, and Doing' Social
Service Review.June.pp. 185-201 .
Lewis,1. & Meredith,B.(1988) , Daughers Caring for Mothers: The
Experience of Caring and Its Implications for Professional Helpers'
Ageing and Society, 8(1) Mar. 1-21.
Lingsom, S.(1994) 'Payments for Care: The Case of Norway' ,in Evers et al.
pp. 67-86
Linsk, N.L., S. Keigher and S.E. Osterbusch (1988) 'State Policies
Regarding Paid Family Caregiving', The Gerontologist 28(2):204-12.
Lister, R. (1990) 'Women, Economic Dependency and Citizenship' Journal
of Social Policy, 7:4, 445-67.
MacRae, H.M. (1995)'Women and Caring: Constructing Self through
Others' Journal of Women and Aging, Vol. 7 No. 1-2, pp. 145-167.
Pascall 0.(1986) 'Social Policy-A Feminist Clitique'.in Social Policy:A
Feminist Analysis., London:Tavistock.Chap.l,pp.I-33.
'Caring and Social Policy' r&] J:.,Chap.3,pp. 71-10 1.
Pijl, M(1994) 'When Private Care Goes Public. An Analysis of Concepts
and Principles Concerning Payments for Care' in Evers, A. et aI., pp.
3-18
Pijl, M and T. Mandemaker and H.J.van Daal and B. Schoonrnan(1994)
'Payments for Care: The Case of The Netherlands' in Evers et a1.,
Randall, V.(1995) 'The Irresponsible State? The Politics of Child Daycare
Provision in Blitain', British Journal of Policy Science 25,327-348 0
Reinharz, S (1983) , Experiential analysis: A Contribution to Feminist
Research' in O. Bowles and R.D.Klein (eds) Theories of Women's
Studies, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Sally, B. & 1. Twigg (1991) 'Women and Community Care- Reflections of a
Debate' in Maclean, M. and D. Groves(eds) Women's issues in Social
Policy. New York: Routledge.
Sipila, 1. (1995) 'Financial Support for Informal Care in Britain, Finland
and Michigan: A Comparison of System Functions' International Social
Work Vol.38,pp.175-189
Sipila,1. (1993) 'Home Care Allowances for the Frail Elderly in Finland-A
Contradictory Innovation', in Evers, A. and 1. Svetlik (eds) Balancing
Pluralism - New Welfare Mixes in Care for the Elderly Chap.13
pp.255-276. Avebury. Aldershot.
Sipila, J & B.L. Simon.(1993) 'Home Care Allowance for the Frail
Elderly:For and Against'. Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare.20(3)
pp.119-134
(1995) 'The Irresponsible State?The Politics of Child Daycare
Provision ill Britain'. British Journal of Political Science
25,Jul,pp.327-348.
Sipila, J and A. Anttonen(1994) 'Payments for Care: The Case of Finland'
in Evers, A. et al. pp.52-66.
Stone, R. & S.M.Keigher(1994) 'Toward and Equitalbe, Universal
Caregiver Policy: The Potential of Financial Supports for Family
Caregivers' JOUlnal of Aging & Social Policy, Vol. 6(112) 57-75.
Thomas. C(1993) 'De-constructing Concepts of Care'. Sociology.27,4, pp.
649-669
Tornstam, L.( )Fonnal and Informal Support for the Elderly. An Analysis
of Present Patterns and Future Options in Sweden' Impact of Science
on Society, 39,1(153),57-63.
Troll,L.E.(1987) 'Gender Differences in Cross-Generation Networks' Sex
Roles 17(11-12) Dec, 751-766.
Twigg, 1. & K. Atkin(1994),Carers Perceived: Policy and Practice In
Informal Care'
Ungerson, C.(1995) 'Gender, Cash and Informal Care:European
Perspectives and Dilemmas' Journal of Social Policy 24,1,31-52
(1983) 'Why do women care? ' ~ J:..,Chap.2,pp.31-49.
(1993) 'Payments for caring- Mapping a Territory', in R. Page and N.
Keakin(eds) The Costs of Welfare, pp. 149-64. Aldershot: Avebwy
(1994) 'Morals and Politics in "payments for Care': An Introductory
Note' in Evers, A. et al. pp.43-47.
(1990)'The Language of Care: Crossing the Boundaries' in Ungerson,
C. (ed) Gender and Caring: Work and Welfare in Britain and
Scandinavia, HarvesterfWheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead.
Waemess,K.(1984) , The Rationality of Caring' Economic and Industrial
Democracy 5(2), May, 185-211.
Walby, S.(1994 )'Is Citizenship Gendred?' Sociology Vol. 28 No.2 pp.
379-395.
Walker, A.J. (1992) Conceptual Perspectives on Gender and Family
Caregiving. in Dwyer J.W. & Coward R.T. (eds) , Gender,
Fmnilies, and Elder Care' ch3 pp.34-46
Walker, A. (1987) 'The Poor Relation: Poverty among Old' inn Glendinning,
C. and Millar, 1. (eds) "Women and Poverty in Britain" pp.178-198.
Wolfe, A.(l989)The day-care dilemma:a Scandinavian perspective, The
Public Interest pp.14-23
Wood, J.T.(1994)'Wbo Cares? Women, Care and Culture' Southern Illiois
University.
(限達賢圖書館四樓資訊教室A單機使用)