| 研究生: |
鄭曉時 |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
霍布斯主權論的理論基礎 無 |
| 指導教授: | 朱堅章 |
| 學位類別: |
碩士
Master |
| 系所名稱: |
社會科學學院 - 政治學系 Department of Political Science |
| 論文出版年: | 1980 |
| 畢業學年度: | 68 |
| 語文別: | 中文 |
| 論文頁數: | 112 |
| 中文關鍵詞: | 無 |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:280 下載:0 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
如果說霍布斯的整個思想像一座冰山,則其絕對主權論只是浮出水面、最引人注目的一部份而已,更重要的是用以支持主權理論的論理基礎。但這些基礎與絕對主權論之間的關係往往被人所忽略,以致有些學者只注意絕對主權論而聯想到現代的極權主義,另一些學者則過於強調論理基礎部份而稱霍布斯為自由主義或個人主義之父,甚或憲政自由民主的真正始祖。本研究的旨趣,並不在將霍布斯的思想劃歸何種主義,而在探討絕對的主權論與其論理基礎之間的關係,指出兩者並不完全一致。
霍布斯的論證模式――自然狀態、契約和國家(主權)三部曲――不但對Spinoza、Locke、Rousseau等思想家有顯著的影響,並且為主權理論提供了兩個論理基礎:1.建立主權的目的在獲得更大的利益,2.建立主權的方式基於人民的同意與授權。
先就建立主權的目的而言,依霍布斯的看法,秩序的有無是人們的欲求能否實現的充份條件,而秩序的有無則端賴政府的有無;他所說的自然狀態卽是無政府狀態,用以闡述為了達到功利目的,人類社會生活必需有主權。如就邏輯上而言,自然狀態的反面只是有主權(政府)的狀態,並不必堅持非有絕對的主權不可;霍布斯堅持凡主權都必須絕對而不受限制,很可能造成違反建立主權目的的情況。
次就建立主權的方式而言,霍布斯從自然狀態作直線式的推論,認為由自然狀態進入國家需經訂立政治契約的程序,而契約則說明了主權的起源及其合法性都基於人民的授權與同意。但授權與同意等槪念並不適於支持絕對主權論,並且,如將霍布斯的主權理論作合理的推演,並不能得出絕對而不受限制的主權。
從上述絕對主權論與其論理基礎的不一致性來看,霍布斯倡導絕對的主權論主要似是受到現實政治動亂的影響。
第一章 導論1
第一節 研究的目的與範圍1
第二節 內戰與方法對霍布斯的影響3
第三節 研究的資料9
註釋10
第二章 建立主權的必要性15
第一節 缺乏主權的弊害15
第二節 建立主權的利益19
第三節 建立主權的必要25
第四節 評論30
註釋34
第三章 主權的特質與條件41
第一節 主權槪念41
第二節 主權的特質45
第三節 主權的條件51
第四節 評論58
註釋62
第四章 建立主權的方式69
第一節 同意與授權69
第二節 建立的主權與取得的主權73
第三節 民主、貴族與君主政體77
第四節 評論81
註釋83
第五章 結論87
第一節 霍布斯主權論的不一致性87
第二節 霍布斯主權論的貢獻91
第三節 餘論93
註釋95
主要參考書目97
一、霍布斯原著的現代版
1. Cropsey, Joseph, ed. and with an introduction. A Dialogue between a Philosopher and a Student of the Common Laws of England. Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1971.
2. Lamprecht, Sterling P., ed. and with an introduction. De Cive or The Citizen. New York: Appleton Century Crofts Inc.. 1971. (with certain chapters relating to theology and scripture omitted).
3. Molesworth, Sir William, ed. Behemoth: The History of the Causes of the Civil Wars of England. New York: Burt Franklin, 1963.
4. Oakeshott, Michael, ed. and with an introduction, Leviathan or the Matter, Forme and Power of a Commonwealth Ecclesiasticall and Civil. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1955.
5. Tö nnies, Ferdinand, ed. with a preface and critical notes,2nd ed. with a new introduction by M.M. Goldsmith..The Elements of Law: Natural and Politic . New York : Barnes & Noble, Inc., 1969.
6. Woodbridge, Frederick J. E., ed. and with an introduction. Hobbes: Selections. New York : Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1930.
7.朱敏章譯。利維坦。王雲五主編,人人文庫,台一版。台北:台灣商務印書館,民國六十一年
二、現代學者的論著
1. Bay, Christian. The Structure of Freedom. New York: Atheneum, 1965.
2. Bowle, John. Hobbes and His Critics: A Study of Seventeenth Century Constitutionalism. New York: Oxford University Press, 1952.
3. Brown, K. C. ed. Hobbes Studies. Oxford :Basil Blackwell, 1965.
4. Burtt, Edwin A., ed. and with an introduction. The English Philosophers from Bacon to Mill. New York :The Modern Library, 1939.
5. Coleman, Frank M. Hobbes and America: Exploring the Constitutional Foundation. Toronto :University of Toronto Press, 1977.
6. Copleston, Frederick S. J. A History of Philosophy . 8 vols. 台北:馬陵出版社翻印,民國六十一年,vol.5 :Modern Philosophy: The British Philosophers, part 1. Hobbes to Paley.
7. Eccleshall, Robert. Order and Reason in Politics : Theories of Absolute and Limited Monarchy in Early Modern England. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978.
8. Gauthier, David P. The Logic of Leviathan: the Moral and Political Theory of Thomas Hobbes. Oxford :Oxford University Press, 1969.
9. Germino, Dante, Modern Western Political Thought : Machiavelli to Marx. Chicago : Rand McNally, 1972.
10. Goldsmith, M. M. Hobbes’s Science of Politics. New York: Columbia University Press, 1966.
11. Jouvenel, Bertrand de. Sovereignty: An Inquiry into the Political Good. trans. J. F. Huntington. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1963.
12. Lemos, Ramon M. Hobbes and Locke: Power and Consent. Georgia: Georgia University Press, 1978.
13. Lymon, Windolph F. Leviathan and Natural Law. New York: Princeton University Press, 1951.
14. Macpherson, C. B, The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke. London :Oxford University Press.1962.
15. McNeilly, F. C. The Anatomy of Leviathan. New York :St. Martin’s Press, 1968.
16. Oakeshott, Michael, Hobbes on Civil Association. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1975.
17. _______ . Rationalism in Politics―and other Essays. New York: Basic Books, 1962.
18. Oppenheim, Felix E. Moral Principles in Political Philosophy. 2nd ed. with a postscript. New York: Random House, 1975.
19. Parry, Geraint. gen. ed., Political Thinkers. London : George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1977. no. 6 : Hobbes : Morals and Politics, by D. D. Raphael.
20. Plamenatz, John. Man and Society. New York :McGraw-Hill, 1963.
21. _______ . The English Utilitarians. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1949.
22. Richardson, R. C. The Debate on the English Revolution. London: Methuen & Co. Ltd., 1977.
23. Sabine, George H. A History of Political Theory. 3th 台北:中央圖書供應社翻印,民國六十年,
24. Sait, Edward Mc Chesney ed., Masters of Political Thought . 3vols. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1966. vol.2 : Machiavelli to Bentham, by W.T. Jones.
25. Spragens, Thomas A. Jr. The Politics of Motion――The World of Thomas Hobbes. with a foreword by Antony Flew. Lexington : University Press of Kentucky, 1973.
26. Stankiewicz, W. J. ed. In Defense of Sovereignty. New York: Oxford University Press, 1969.
27. Strauss, Leo. Natural Right and History. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1953.
28. _______ , The Political Philosophy of Hobbes : Its Basis and its Genesis. trans. Else M. Sinclair. Phoenix Books: Chicago University Press, 1963.
29. Vaughan, Charles E. Studies in the History of Political Philosophy before and after Rousseau. 2 vols.ed. A. G. Little. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1925. vol. 1: From Hobbes to Hume.
30. Warrender, Howard. The Political Philosophy of Hobbes: His Theory of Obligation. Oxford : Clarendon Press, 1957.
31. Watkins, J.W.N. Hobbes’s System of Ideas――A Study in the Political Significance of Philosophical Theories. New York: Barnes & Noble, 1968.
32. Zagorin, Perez. A History of Political Thought in the English Revolution. New York: Humanities Press, 1966.
33.朗格(Friederick Albert Lange)。朗格唯物論史,上下兩册。李石岑譯。台北:台灣中華書局,民國四十六年台一版。上册。
34.鄒文海遺著。西洋政治思想史稿。朱堅章編。台北:鄒文海先生獎學基金會,民國六十一年。
35.國立編譯館編著。西洋政治思想史。台北:國立編譯館,民國五十九年臺修訂五版。
三、期刊論文
1. Aaron, R.I. “Possible Early Draft of Hobbes’s De Corpore.” Mind 54 (October 1946) 342-356.
2. Ackerman, T. F. “Two Concepts of Moral Goodness in Hobbes's Ethics. “ Journal of the History of Philosophy 14 (October 1976 ) 415-425.
3. Ake, C. “Social Contract Theory and the Problem of Politicization: the Case of Hobbes.” Western Political Quarterly 23 ( September 1970 ) 463-470.
4. Anglim, John. “On Locke’s States of Nature.” Political Studies 26: no. 1 (March 1978).
5. Ashcraft, Richard. “Hobbes’s Natural Man: A Study in Ideology Formation.” Journal of Politics 3( November 1971 ) 1076-1117.
6. _______ . “Ideology and Class in Hobbes’s Political Theory. “ Political Theory 6 : no. 1 (February 1978 ).
7. Beakon, Steve., and Reeve, Andrew. “The Benefits of Reasonable Conduct: The Leviathan Theory of Obligation. “ Political Theory 4 : no.4 (November 1976).
8. Brown, S. M. “Hobbes : The Taylor Thesis. “ Philosophical Review 68 ( 1959) 303-323. ed. in Hobbes Studies by K. C. Brown.
9. Campbell, B. “Prescription and Description in Political Thought : the Case for Hobbes, “ American Political Science Review 65 (January 1971) 376-388.
10. Catlin, G.E.G. “Thomas Hobbes and Contemporary Political Theory. “ Political Science Quarterly 82 (March 1967) 1-13.
11. Engel, S. Morris, “Hobbes’s Table of Absurdity.” Philosophical Review 70 (1961 ) 533-543. ed. in Hobbes Studies by K. C. Brown.
12. Glover, W. B. “God and Thomas Hobbes. “ Church History 29 ( September 1960) 275-297. ed. in Hobbes Studies by K. C. Brown.
30. Schlatter, Richard, “Thomas Hobbes and Thucydides.” Journal of the History of Ideas 6 (1945) 350-362.
31. Schochet, G. J. “Thomas Hobbes on the Family and the State of Nature.” Political Science Quarterly 82 ( September 1967) 427-445.
32. Skinner, Quinton. “Hobbes on Sovereignty: an Unknown Discussion. “Political Studies 13 (February 1968 ) 213-218.
33. Tarlton, Charles D. “The Creation and Maintenance of Government: A Neglected Dimension of Hobbes’s Leviathan.” Political Studies 26 : no. 3 ( September 1978 ).
34. Taylor, A. E. “The Ethical Doctrine of Hobbes.” Philosophy 13 (1938 ) 406-424. ed. in Hobbes Studies by K. C. Brown.
35. Watkins, J.W.N. “Philosophy and Politics in Hobbes” Philosophical Quarterly 5 (1955) 125-146.ed.in Hobbes Studies by K.C. Brown.
36.― ―. “ Posthumous Career of Thomas Hobbes.” Review of Politics 19 ( July 1957) 351-360.
37. Williamson, Colwyn. “Hobbes on Law and Coercion.” Ethics 80 ( January 1970 ) 146-155.
38. ― ―. “Contradiction in Hobbes’s Analysis of Sovereignty.” Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 32(May 1966)202-219.
39.朱堅章。「霍布斯的自由觀念」。思與言,6卷5期(民國五十八年一月)。
40.李華煦。「霍布士的國家機械論」。復興崗學報,第1期(民國五十年一月)。
(限達賢圖書館四樓資訊教室A單機使用)