跳到主要內容

簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 單小琳
論文名稱: 教師成就動機與學生評定教師.學生學業成績的關係
指導教授: 吳靜吉
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 教育學院 - 教育學系
Department of Education
論文出版年: 1980
畢業學年度: 68
語文別: 中文
論文頁數: 258
中文關鍵詞:
相關次數: 點閱:10下載:0
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 有關教師效能的研究可由三方面著手:準備、過程及成果階段。本研究由上述三者分別選擇教師的成就動機、學生評定教師及學業成績三個變數,以探討教師成就動機與學生評定教師、學生學業成績的關係。本研究目的有三:
    1.應用Helmreich & Spence的成就動機理論,瞭解本國教師的適用情形。
    2.探討教師成就動機對學生的影響,作為辦理教師訓練時的參考。
    3.提供有關教師效能實證研究的工具或途徑。
    本研究以基隆市六年級全體師生為對象,分別以「工作與家庭取向量表」、「我的級任老師」、「學科成就測驗」為測量工具,作普查式的施測,計樣本有教師145人,學生6103人,經界定成就動三因素的高、低分組後,實際參與統計分析的樣本有教師82人,學生3875人。
    自變項為成就動機,分為三項:精熟、工作取向、競爭;依變項有二:在學生評定教師上包括教師的溫暖、職權、個人品質、教學技巧及總評定五項;在學生學業成績上包括國語、數學、常識及總分四項。統計方法以2×2×2三因式不等組變異數分析,結果發現:
    1.教師成就動機中工作取向與競爭的交互作用對學生有影響:工作取向、競爭均偏低傾向的教師,在學生所知覺的好教師上被評定較優。
    2.教師成就動機中精熟對學生有影響:精熟高的教師,在學生所知覺的好教師上被評定較優。
    3.教師不同程度的成就動機對學生的學業成績沒有影響;惟教師有低工作取向時,其所教的學生在國語科及三科總分上成績較高。
    上述結果除了在高精熟方面支持Helmreich & Spence的論點外,其餘均未獲得證驗。尤其是具有高工作取向的教師並未發現對學生產生有益的影響。
    因此,本研究建議:1.不再加強或訓練教師的工作取向,以免過度的工作要求導致教師影響學生行為產生負向的反映。2.安排各類新知能的成長機會與挑戰情況,促使教師發揮較高的精熟度。
    另外,建議學生評定教師部份將繼續探究,俾提供教師當做囘饋並改善行為的參考。其次將Helmreich & spence的成就動機結構施用於企業界俾為效度及差異趨勢上,求得進一步的探證。


    第一章 緒論
    第一節 引言1
    第二節 問題與假設9
    第三節 操作定義14
    第二章 文獻探討
    第一節 成就動機18
    第二節 學生評定教師39
    第三節 學生學業成績54
    第四節 成就動機與學生評定教師、學生學業成績61
    第三章 研究方法
    第一節 樣本選取69
    第二節 測量工具77
    第三節 施測程序117
    第四章 研究結果
    第一節 統計結果的分析121
    第二節 假設的驗證217
    第五章 討論、結論與建議
    第一節 討論221
    第二節 結論227
    第三節 建議231
    參考書目234
    附錄 一、工作與家庭取向量表
    二、我的級任老師

    一、中文部份:
    水 心等 教師態度研究台 灣書店民 民67.7.
    王書林譯 心理學——行為科學導言 正中書局 民61.
    汪榮才 教師行為、學生制握信念與學業成就 台南師專學報第12.期第111〜131頁 民68.
    何英奇 成敗經驗對自我評價與抱負水準之影響 師大碩士論文、師大教研所集刊 民66.6.
    吳宗賢 學生個人品質與教師期待及喜歡的關係 師大碩士論文、師大教研所集刊 民66.6.
    林清山 心理與教育統計學 東華書局 民63.9.
    林本 現代的理想教師 台灣開明書局二版 民64.4.
    金樹人 國中學生動機水準、工作難度、合作與競爭,對工作表現及焦慮狀態之影響 師大碩士論文、師大教研所集刊 民68.6.
    張煌熙 國中編班方式與學生學習動機之關係 師大教研所主編 教育心理學第487〜553頁 民68.6.
    張春興 心理學概要 東華書局三版 民68.3
    葉重新 心理測驗 大洋書局 民68.
    程法泌 測驗在輔導上的應用 台灣教育輔導月刊社 民60.
    賈馥茗 學生所期望之教師品質 測驗年刊 民59.1.
    廖克玲 領導績效的變通模式在教學情境中之應用 台大心研所碩士論文 民67.
    鄭伯壎 組織行為之管理心理學 大洋書局 民67.4.

    二、英文部分
    Ach, N. “Uber den willensakt und das temperamer”. 1910, In R. L. Helmreich, & J. T. Spence, “The work and family orientation questionnaire : an objective instruct to assess components of achievement motivation and attitudes toward family and career”. J. Supplement Abstract Service. 1978,8(2),35.
    Achenback, T. A. “Comparison of Standford-Binet performances of retarded and nonretarded persons matched for MA and sex”. American J. of Mental Deficiency. 1970,74,488-494.
    Allport, G. W. “The ego incontemporary psychology”. Psychological Reviews,1943,50,451-478.
    Aronson, E. “The need for achievement as measure by graphic expression”. In J. W. Atkinson, Motive In Fanstansy, Action, and Society. Princeton: Van Nostrand, 1958.
    Atkinson, J. W., & Feather, N. T. A Theory Achievement Motivation. N. Y.: Wiley, 1966.
    Atkinson, J. W., & Litwin, G. H. “Achievement motive and test anxiety conceived as motive to approach success and motive avoid failure”. J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1960,60,52-63.
    Atkinson, J. W., & Cartwright, D. “Some neglected variable in comporary conceptions of decision and performance“. Psychological Reports, 1964,14,575-590.
    Atkinson, J. W., & Birch, D. The Dynamics of Action. N. Y.: Wiley, 1970.
    Atkinson, J. W., & Raynor, J. C. Motivation and Achievement . Washington, D. C.: V. H. Winston & Sons, 1974.
    Atkinson, J. W. “A new preface with hindsight”. In D. C. McClell and, The Achievement Motive. N. Y.: John, Wiley& Sons, 1976.
    Ausubel, D. P. Educational Psychology. N. Y.: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1968.
    Beck, W. R. “Pupil’s perceptions of teacher merit : A factor analysis of five postulated dimensions”. J. Educational Psychology, 1967, (Nov.),61,127-128.
    Belgard, M., Rosenshine, B.,& Gage, N. L. “The teacher’s effectiveness in explaining; evidence on its generality and correlation with pupils’ ratings and attention scores”. Explorations of Teachers Effectiveness in Explaining. Technical Report, No.4.
    Belier, E. K. “Research in organized programs of early education”. In R. M. W. Travers, Second Hand- book of Research On Teaching. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1973.
    Birney, R. C., Burdick, H., & Teevean, R. C. Fear of Failure. N. Y.: Van Nostrand, 1969.
    Brophy, J. E., Coulter, C, L., Crawford, W. J., Evertson, C, M.,& King, C. E. “Classroom observation scale stability across time and context and relationship with student learning gains”. J. Educational Psychology,1975,7,873-881.
    Braskamp, L. A., Caullay, D., & Costin, F. “Student ratings instructor self-ratings and their relationship to student achievement”. American Educational Research J., 1979,16(3), 295-306.
    Borich, G. D.,& Fenton, K. S. The Appraisal of Teaching Concepts and Process. Mass: Addinson-Wesley, Pub., 1977a.
    Borich, G. D., & Madden, S. K. Evaluating Classroom Instruction : A Sourcebook of Instrutments. Mass.: Addison-Wesley, Pub., 1977b.
    Bowers, N. D., & Soar, R. S. “Studies of human relations in the teaching-learning process”. In N. A. Flanders, Teacher Effectiveness, Gage, Encyclopedia of Educational Research, Macmillan, 1969,1430.
    Burkhard, M. I. “Discrenment of teacher characteristics by TAT sequence analysis”. J. Educational Psychology, 1962, 53,279-287.
    Centra, T. A. “The how and why of evaluating teaching”. New Directions for Higher Education. 1977,7,67-78a.
    Certra, J. A. “Student ratings of instruction and their relationship to student learning”. American Educational Research J., 1977, 14,17-24b.
    Chaikin, A. L. etal, “Student’s reactions teacher’s physical attractiveness and nonverbal behavior: two exploratory studies”. Psycholog In School, 1978 (Oct.), 15(4), 588-595.
    Coats, W. D., Swierenga, L.,& Wickert, J. “Student perception of teachers: a factor analytic study”. J. Educational Research, 1972(Apr. ),65(8),357-361.
    Cohen, S. A., & Berger W, G. "Dimensions of student’s ratings of college instructors underlying subsequent achievement on course examinations", Porceedings of the 178th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Assoc., 1970,5,605-606.
    Costin, F., Greenough, W. T.,& Menges, R.J. “Student ratings of college teaching: reliability, validity and usefulness”. Review of Educational Research, 1971,41, 511-535.
    Crandall, V. C. “Achievement behavior in young children”. In W. W. Hartup, & N. L. Smothergill, The Young Child: Reviews of Research. Washington, D. C. : National Assoc. for the Education of Young Children, 1967.
    Chunninqham, W. G. “The impact of student-teacher pairings on teacher effectiveness”. American Educational Research J., 1975,12,169-189.
    Dalton, E. L. “Pupil selection of teachers”. Educational Leadership, 1971, 28(5),476-479.
    Dandes, H. M. “Psychological health and teaching effectiveness”. J. of Teacher Education, 1966 ,4(18) ,301-306.
    Davidoff, S. H. “The development of an instrument designed to secure student assessment of teaching behavior that correlate with objective measures of student achievement," In G. D. Borich, 1977a.
    DeCharms, R. Enhancing Motivation : Change In the Classroom . N. Y.: Irvington ,1976.
    Dias, S. L. "A study of personal, perceptual, and motivation factors influential in predicting the aspiration. level of women and men toward the administrative role in education”. P. Colling, Dissertation Abstracts International. Helen Greenway, Pub., 1975(Sept.),36,3,1202A.
    Di Marco, N. “Life style learning structure, congruence and student attitude”, American Educational Research J., 1974,11,203-209.
    Doyle, K. O., & Whitely, S. E. “Student rating as criteria for effective teaching”. American Educational Research ,1974,11, 259-274.
    Dunkin, M. J., & Biddle, B. J. The Study of Teaching. N. Y.: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, Inc., 1974.
    Ebel, K. B. The Recognition and Evaluation of Teaching, Washington, D. C.: American Assoc, of Univ. Professors,1971.
    Elmore, P. B.,& LaPointe, K. A. “Effect of teacher sex, student sex, and teacher warmth on the evaluation of college instructors”. J. Educational Psy.,1975,67,368-374.
    Feather, N. T. “Teaching effectiveness and student evaluation". In W. J. McKeachie, Instructional Psy., Annual Review Psychology, 1974,167-170.
    Feigelson, S. B. “Effects of the achievement motivation program, a human potential approach, on student teachers’ perceptions of self and others”. P. Coiling, Dissertation Abstracts International, Helen Greenway ,Pub., 1974,35(5),2822A.
    Fernandez, C., Espinosa, R. W.,& Dornbusn, S. M. Factor Perpetuating the Low Academic Status of Chicago High School Students. Stanford Center for Research and Development in Teaching, Stanford Univ., 1975.
    Festinger, L. A. “Theoretical interpretation of shifts in level of aspiration”. Psychological Review, 1942 , 49,235-250.
    Flanagan, D. E. “ A study of the relationship of scores on the MMPI to success in teaching as indicated by supervisory ratings”. J. Experimental Ed.,1961,29,329-354.
    Flanders, N. A. Teacher Influence Pupil Attitudes and Achievement, Minneapolis: Univ., of Minnesota, 1960.
    Flanders, N. A. “Teacher effectiveness”, In R. L. Ebel, Encyclopedia of Educational Research (4ed), American Educational Research Assoc., Macmillan Co., 1969.
    French, E. G. “Development of a measure of complex motivation”. In J. W. Atkinson, Motives in Fantasy: Action, and Society. Princeton: Van Nostrand, 1958.
    French, E., & Lesser, G. S. “Some characteristics of the achievement motive in women”. J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1964, 68,119-128.
    French-Lazovik, G. “Predictability of students’ evaluations of college teachers from component ratings”. J. Educational Psychology, 1974,66,373-385.
    Frey, P. W. “Student instructional ratings and faculty performance”. In W, J. McKeachie, Instructional Psy., Annual Review Psychology, 1974,167-170.
    Frey, P. W., Leonard, D. W., & Beatty, W. W. “Student ratings of instructions: validation research”. American Educational Research J., 1975,12,435-447.
    Frey, P. W. “A two-dimensional analysis of student ration of instruction”, Research in Higher Education , 1978,9(1),69-71.
    Friedman, I. “Objectifying the subjective- a methodological approach to the TAT”. 1957, In N. L. Gage, Handbook of Research On Teaching. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963, 506-582.
    Fortune, J. C. A Study of the Generality of Presenting Behavior in Teaching Preschool Children. Memphis, Tenn.: Memphis State Univ., 1967.
    Fortune, J. C., Gage, N. L., & Shutes, R. E. “The generality of the ability of explain:. 1966. In
    B. Rosenshine, Evaluation of classroom instruction, Educational Research, 1970,40(2), 279-300.
    Gage, N. L., Leavitt, G. S.,& Stone, G. C. “Teachers’ understanding of their pupils and pupils’ ratings of their teachers”. 1959, 1969, In G. D. Borich, & S. K. Madden, Evaluating Classroom Instruction: Sourcebook of Instrument. Mass.: Addison-Wesley, Pub. 1977.
    Gage, N. L. “The appraisal of college teaching an analysis of ends and means”. J. of Higher Education, 1961,32,17-22.
    Gage, N. L. Handbook of Research On Teaching. Chicago: Rand McNally Co., 1963.
    Gage, N. L., Runkel, P. J.,& Chatlerjee, B. B.”Changing teacher behavior though feedback from pupils: an application of equilibrum theory”. In A. Rotem, On the effectiveness of students’ evaluative feedback to Univ. instructors. Review of Educational Research, 1979(Sum.) 49 (3), 497-511.
    Gage, N. L. Teacher Effectiveness and Teacher Education. Calif.; Pacific Books, Pub.,1972.
    Gage, N. L. “Students’ ratings of college teaching: their justification and proper use”, 1974, In A. Rotem. On the effectiveness of students’ evaluative feedback to Univ. instructors. Review of Educational Research, 1979(Sum), 49(3),497-511.
    Gagne, R. The Conditions of Learning, N. Y.: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1977.
    Garber, M.,& Ware, W. B. “The home environment as a Predictor of school achievement”. In R. S. Soar, Teacher assessment problems and possibilities. J. of Teacher Education, 1973, 24, 205- 212.
    Gessner, P. K. “Evaluation of instruction”. Science, 1973,180,566-570.
    Getzels, J, W.,& Jackson, P. W. “The teacher’s personality and characteristics”. In N. L. Gage, Handbook of Research on Teaching, Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963.
    Gillmore, P. K., Kanz, M. R., & Narracato, R. W. “The generalizability of student ratings of instruction: estimation of the teacher and course components”. J. of Educational Measurement, 1978,15(1),1-13.
    Gough, H. G. Manual for the California Psychological Invernory. Palo Alto, Calif. Consulting Psychologists Press, 1960.
    Granzin, K. L.,& Painter, J. J. “A new explanation for students’ course evaluation tendencies”. American Educational Research J., 1973,10,115-124.
    Grasha, A. F. “The role of internal instructor frames of reference in the student ratings process”, J. Educational Psychology, 1975,67,451-460.
    Grush, J. C.,& Costin, F. ”The student as consumer of the teaching process". American Educational Research J., 1975,12,55-66.
    Haak, R. A, Kleiher, D. A.,& Peck, R. F. Manual: Student Evaluation of Teacher Instrument, II. Austin: Texas: The Research and Development Center for Teacher Education, The Unic, of Texas, 1972.
    Heckhausen, H. “Hoffnung und furcht in der leistungs motivation”. 1963, Encyclopedia of Psychology, Vol.1.
    Heckhausen, H. The Anatomy of Achievement Motivation, N. Y.: Academic Press, 1967.
    Heil, L. M.,& Washburne, C. “Characteristics of teachers related to children’s progress”. J. Teacher Education, 1961,12,401-406.
    Helmreich, R. L., Beane, W., Lucker, G. W.,& Spence, J. T. “Achievement motivation and scientific attainment”. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1978,4, 222-226.
    Helmreich, R. L, & Spence, J. T. “Work and family orientation questionnaire: an objective instrument to assess components of achievement motivation and attitudes toward family and career": J. Supplement Abstracts Service, 1978,8(2),35.
    Henry, B. M. “Need for achievement and aspiration for upward mobility of female and male elementary teachers in Virginia”. 1977, P. Colling, Dissertation Abstracts International. Helen Greenway, Pub., 1978,38,pt.1,
    Herrenkohl, R. C., ”Factor-analytic and criterion study of achievement orientation”. J. Educational Psychology, 1972,63,4,314-326.
    Hoffman, L. W. “Fear of success in males and females: 1965 and 1971”. J. Counsulting and Clinical Psychology. 1974,42(3), 353-358.
    Hoffman. L. W. “Early childhood experiences and women's achievement motives”. In R. L. Helmreich, & J. T. Spence, Work and family orientation questionnaire. J. Supplement Abstract Service9 1978,8(2),35.
    Hoffman, R. G. “Variables affecting Univ. student ratings of Instructor behavior”. American Educational Research J., 1978(Spr.),15(2), 287-299.
    Horner, M. S. “Sex differences in achievement motivation and performance incompetitive and non- competitive stitution”, 1968. In G. W. Dalton, & P. R. Lawrence, Motivation and Control in Organizations . Ill.: Richard D. Irwin, 1971.
    Howsam, R. B. Who’s A Good Teachers? Problems and Progress in Teacher Evaluation. Calif. Teachers Assoc., 1960.
    Isaacson, R. L., McKeachie, W. J.,& Milholland, J.E, “Correlation of teacher personality, variables, and student ratings”, J. Educational Psychology, 1963, 54,110-117.
    Isaacson, R. L. “Dimensions of students evaluations of teaching”. J. Educational Psychology, 1964,55,344-351.
    Jack, D. N., Ahmed, S. A., & Heapy, N. A. “Is achievement a unitary construct?”. J. of Research In Personality, 1976,10,1-21.
    Jaeger, R. M.,& Freijo, T. D. “Some psychometric questions”. J. Educational Psychology, 1974,66,416-423.
    Johnson, G. B. Jr. “An evaluation instrument for the analysis of teacher effectiveness”. J. Experimental Education. 1955,23,331-344.
    Johnson, G. B. Jr. “An experimental technique for the prediction of teacher effectiveness”, J. Educational Research, 1957,50,679-689.
    Keeves, J. P. The Home Environment and Education Achievement. Australian National Univ. Research School of Social, Dept. of Sociology, Oct., 1970.
    Kennedy, W. R, “Grades espected and grades received their relationship to students’ evaluations of faculty performance”. J. Educational Psychology, 1975,67,109-116.
    Kirk, R. E. Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences. ,1970.
    Kulik, J. A., & McKeachie, W. J. “The evaluation of teachers in higher education”. 1975, In M. C. Wittrock, & A. A. Lumsdaine, Instructional psychology, Annual Review Psychology, 1977,28,417-459.
    Lesser, G. S., Krawitz, R. N.,& Packard, R. "Experimental arousal of achievement motivation in adolescentgirls”. J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1963,66,59-66.
    Lewin, K. A Dynamic Theory of Personality. McGraw- Hill, 1935.
    Lewin, K. and Others, ”Level of aspiration”. In J.M. Hunt, Personality and the Behavioral Disorders. Vol.1, Ranald, 1944, 333-378.
    Lewis, J. Appraising Teacher Performance. N. Y.: Parker Pub. Co., Inc., 1973.
    Lynn, R. “An achievement motivation questionnaire ,“. British J. of Psychology, 1969,60(4),529-534.
    Mandler, G., & Cowen, J. E. “Test anxiety questionnaires”. J. of Counsulting Psychology, 1958,22, 228-229.
    Mandler, G., & Sarason, S. B. “A study of anxiety and learning". J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1952, 47,166-173.
    Marques, T. E., Lane, D. M., & Dorfman, P. W. “ Toward the development of a system for instructional evaluation is there consensus regarding what constitute effective teaching?". J. Educational Psychology , 1979(Dec.),76(6),840-849.
    Marsh, H. W., Fleiner, H.,& Thomas, C. S. “Validity and usefulness of student evaluations of instructional equality”. J. Educational Psychology, 1975,67,833-839.
    Marsh, H. W., Overall, J. U.,& Thomas, C. S. “The relationship between student’s evaluation of instruction and expected grade”. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Assoc. San Francisco, Apr. 1976. (ERIC. Document Reproductor Service No, ED126 140).
    Marsh, H. W. “The validity of students’ evaluates classroom evaluations of instructors independently nominated as best and worst teachers by graduating seniors.": American Educational Research J., 1977,14, 441-447.
    Marsh, H. W. “Students’ evaluates of instructional effectiveness relationship to student, course, and instructors characteristics”. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Assoc., Toronto, Mar, 1978.(ERIC, Document Reproductor Service No. ED 155 217).
    Marsh, H. W., Overall, J. U., & Kesler, S. P. “Validity of student evaluations of instructional effectiveness: a comparison of faculty self-evaluations and evaluations by their students”. J. Educational Psychology, 1979,71(2),149-160.
    Marsh, H. W. “The influence of student course and instructor characteristics in evaluations of Univ. teaching”. American Educational Research J., 1980,17 (1), 219-237.
    Masters, J. R. “High school student ratings of teacher and teaching methods”. J. Educational Research, 1979 (Mar. ),72, 219-224.
    McClelland, D. C., Atkinson, J. W., Clark, R. A.,& Lowell, F. L. The Achievement Social and Motive N. Y. : Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1953.
    McClelland, D. C. “Methods measureing human motivation”, In J. W, Atkinson, Motives In Fantasy, Action, and Society. Princeton: Van Nostrand,1958.
    McClelland, D. C. The Achieving Society. Princeton: Van Nostrand, 1961.
    McClelland, D. C.,& Winter, D. C. Motivating Economic Achievement. N. Y. : Free Press, 1969.
    McClelland, D. C. Achievement Motive, N. Y.: John, Wiley & Sons, 1976.
    McKeach, W. J. "Research in teaching at the college and Univ. level,” in N. L. Gage, Handbook of Research on Teaching, Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963, 1118-1172.
    McKeachie, W. J. “Student ratings of faculty”. American Assoc, of Univ. Professors Bulletin, 1969, 55, 439-444.
    McKeachie, W. J., Lin, Y. G., & Mann W. “Student ratings of teacher effectiveness”. American Educational Research., 1971, 8, 435-445.
    McKeachie, W. J. “Correlates of student ratings”. in A. L. Sockloff, Proceedings: The First Invitational Conference on Faculty Effectiveness as Evaluated by Students. Philadelphia: Measurement and Research Center, Temple Univ., 1973.
    McKeachie, W. J. “Instructional Psychology”. American Review Psychology, 1974,25,161-193.
    McReynolds, P., & Guevara, C. “Attitude of schizophrenics and normals toward success and failure”. J. of Abnormal Psychology, 1967,72,303-310.
    Medley, D. M. “Teacher personality and teacher-pupil rapport”. J. of Teacher Education, 1961,12,152-156.
    Mednick, M. T. S., Tangri, S. S.,& Hoffman, L. W. Women and Achievement: Social and Motivational Analysis. Washington, D. C.: Hemisphere, 1975.
    Mehrabian, A. “Measures of achieving tendency”. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 1969,29,445-451.
    Mehta, M, “A study of the relationship between job value and need achievement". Manas, 1975(dec.),22(2),219-226.
    Mitzel, H. E. “Teacher effectiveness”, In C. W. Harris, Encyclopedia of Educational Research (3rd).Macmillan, 1960,1481-1486.
    Moody, R. “Student’s achievement and their rating spanish teacher". Modern Language J., 1976(Dec.) 60(8),454-463.
    Monday, L. A., Hout, D. P.,& Lutz, S. W. College Student Profiles: American College Testing Proqram Iowa City: ACT Pub., 1967.
    Morsh, J. E., Burgess, G. G.& Smith, P. N. “Student achievement as a measure of instructor effectiveness”. J. Educational Psychology, 1956,47,79-88.
    Morsh, J. R.,& Wilder. E. W, "Identifying the effective instructor: a review of the quantitative studies”, In J. D. McNeil, & W. J. Phpham, The Assessment of Teacher Competence, Second Handbook of Research On Teaching, Chicago: Rand McNally, 1973,230-236.
    Murray, H. A. Explorations in Personality. N. Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1938.
    Murray, E. “An exploration of the relationship of self-actualization to teacher success". In E. Murray Students’ perceptions of self-actualizing and non- self-actualizing teachers”. J. of Teacher Education.
    O'Connor, P. A., Atkinson, J. W. “An achievement risk preference scale: a preliminary report”, American Psychologist, 1962,17,317.
    Paraskevopoulos, I. “How students rate their teachers”. J. Educational Research, 1968(Sept. ), 62,25-29.
    Peng, S. S. etal, “Teacher affect in relation to pupil achievement”. J. of Teacher Education, 1978,49,76-79.
    Perry, R. P. Abrami, P. C. Leventhal, L.,& Check, J. “Instructor reputation: an expectancy relationship involing student ratings and achievement”. J. Educational Psychology, 1971,71(6),776-787.
    Perry, R. P., Niemi, R., Johnes, K. “Effect of prior teaching evaluations and lecture presentation on ratings of teaching performance”. J. Educational Psychology, 1974,66,851-856.
    Remmers, H. H. “The relationship between student’s marks and student attitude toward instructors”. School and Social, 1928,28,759-760.
    Remmers,H. H. ”The college professor as the Student see him". Purdue Univ. Student Higher Education. 1929,29,75.
    Remmers, H. H., & Elliott, D. N. “Manual for instruction for the Purdue rating scale for instruction”, In H. H. Remmers, & N. L. Gage, Educational Measurement & Evaluation. N. Y.: Harper & Brothers, 1955.
    Remmers, H. H., & Elliott, D. Manual, The Purdue Rating Scale for Instruction. West Lafayette, Indiana: Univ. Book Store, 1960.
    Remmers, H. H. “Rating methods in research on teaching”. In N. L. Gage, Handbook of Research on Teaching. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963,329-378.
    Remmers, H. H., & Baker, P.C. The Purdue Rating Scale of Instruction. Indiana: Purdue Personnel Evaluation Research Service, 1960.
    Remmers, H. H. Manual, The Purdue Rating Scale For Struction. West Lafayette, Indiana: Univ. Book Store, 1970.
    Rezer, A. G. “The influence of needs upon the student’s perception of his instructor”. J. Educational Research, 1965, (Feb.), 58(6),282-286.
    Ringness, T. A.,& Others. “Self-role conflict, personality variables, and classroom interaction”. In R. L. Ebel, Encyclopedia of Educational Research(4 ed), Macmillan Co. 1969,1429.
    Rodin, M., & Rodin, B. “Student evaluation of teachers”. Science, 1972,177,1164-1166.
    Rolfe, J. F. “The measurement of teaching ability”. J. Experimental Education, 1945,14,52-74.
    Rosehthal, R.& Jacobsen, L. Pygmalion In the Classroom: Teacher Expectation and Pupils’ Intellectual Development. N. Y.: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1968.
    Rosenshine, B., Cohen, A.,& Furst, N. “Correlation of student preference ratings”. J. College Student Personnel , 1973,14,269-272.
    Rosenshine, B. Teachinq Behaviors and Student Achievement . Urbana-Champaign: Univ. of Illinois, 1971.
    Rotem, A., & Glasman, N. S. “On the effectiveness of students’ evaluative feedback to Univ. instructors”. Review of Educational Research, 1979(Sum.),49(3),497-511.
    Sears, R. R. ”A theoretical framework for personality and social behavior”. American Psychologist, 1951, 9, 476-483.
    Serow, R. C., & Solomon, D. “Classroom climates and students’ Intergroup behavior”. J. Educational Psychology , 1979,71,669-676.
    Sherman, B. R.& Blackburn, R. T. “Personal characteristics and teaching effectiveness of college faculty”. J. Educational Psychology, 1975,67,124-131.
    Sherwood, J. J. “Self-report and projective measure of achievement and afflication”, J. of Consult Psychology, 1966, 30, 329-337.
    Shingles, R. D. “Faculty ratings: procedures for interpreting student evaluations”. American Educational Research J., 1977,14,459-470.
    Shock, N. W., Kelly, E. L., & Remmers, H. H. “An empirical study of the validity of the Spearman- Brown formula as applied to the Purdue rating scale”. J. Educational Psychology, 1927,18,187-195.
    Smith, C. P. Achievement-Related Motives in Children, N. Y.: Russell Sage Foundation, 1969.
    Soar, R. S. “An integrative approach to classroom learning”. 1966, In Soar, R. S. Teacher assessment problem and possibilities . J. of Teacher Education , 1973, 24, 205-212.
    Solomon, D., Bezdek, W. E., & Rosenberg, L. Teaching Styles and Learning. Chicago: Center for the Study of Liberal Education for Adult, 1963.
    Spence, J. T., Helmreich, R., & Stapp, J. “Ratings of self and peers on sex-role attributes and their relation to self-esteem and conceptions of masculinity and femininity”. J. of Personality and Social Psychology, 1975,32,29-39.
    Spence, J. T., & Helmreich, R. The Psychological Dimensions of Masculinity and Femininity: Their Correlates and Antecedents. The Univ of Texas Press, 1978.
    Stayrook, N. G. “Path analyses relating student perceptions of teacher behavior of student achievement”. J. of Teacher Education. 1978(Mar.),29(2), 51.
    Stecklein, J. E. “Colleges and universities programs: evaluation”. In C. W. Harris, Encyclopedia of Educational Research(3ed), N.Y.: Macmillan, 1960, 285- 289.
    Stumpt, S. A., & Freedman, R. D. “Expected grade covariation with student ratings of instruction individual versus class effect”, J. Educational Psychology,. 1979,71(3), 293-302.
    Sullivan, A., & Skanes, G. “Validity of student evaluations of teaching and characteristics of successful instructors”. J. Educational Psychology , 1974,66,584-590.
    Teglasi, H. “Sex-role orientation achievement & attribution”. Sex-Role, 1978, (June),4, 381-397.
    Tetenbaum, T. J. “The role of student needs & teachers orientations in student ratings of teachers”. American Educational Research J., 1975,12,417-433.
    Tobias, S., & Hanlon, R. “Attitudes toward instructors social desirability and behavioral intentions”. J. Educational Psychology, 1975,67, 405-408.
    Tolor, A. “Evaluation of perceived teachers effectiveness”. J. Educational Psychology, 1973,64,98-104.
    Veldman, D. J.,& Peck, R. F. “Student teacher characteristics from the pupil’s viewpoint”. J. Educational Psychology, 1963, 54,346-355.
    Veldman, D. J., & Peck, R. F. “The pupil observation survey teacher behavior from the pupils’ viewpoint”. 1967, In G. D. Borich, Evaluating Classroom Instruction: A Sources book of Instruments. Mass.: Addison- Wesley, Pub. Co., 1977.
    Veroff, J., Atkinson, J. W., Feld, S., & Gurin, G. “The use of the matic apperceptions to assess motivation in a nation wide interview study ." Psychological Monograph, 1960,74, (12, whole no. 499).
    Veroff, J. “Theoretical background for studying the origins of human motivational disposition”. In D.C. McCelland, Achievement Motive. N. Y.: John, Wiley & Sons, 1976.
    Veroff, J., & Feld, S. Marriage and Work in American. N. Y.: Van Nostrand-Reinhold, 1970.
    Weiner, B. “New conceptions in the study of achievement motivation”. In B. Maher, Progress in Experimental Personality Research. Vol.5, N. Y. Academic Press, 1970.
    Weiner, B. Theories of Motivation. N. Y.: Markham ,1972.
    Weinstein, M. “Achievement motivation and risk preference”. J. of Personality and Social Psychology , 1969,13(2), 153-172.
    Watson, D., & Siegel, J. “Test anxiety, motive to avoid failure, and motive to approach success.” J. Experimental Research in Personality, 1966,1, 236- 243.
    Whaley-Klahn, M. A. etal, “Response of boys and girls to a behaviorally forcused school attitude questionnaire”. J. of Psychology, 1976(Winter), 14(4), 283-290.
    Whitely, S. E., & Doyle, K. O. The Validity and Generalizability of Student Ratings from Between. Class and With-Class Data. Minneapolis: Measurement Services Center, Univ. of Minnesota, 1976.
    Wiley, D. E., & Harnischfeger, A. “Explosion of a myth: quantity of schooling and exposure to in instructions, major educational Vehicles," Educational Research, 1974, 3(4),7-22.
    Wittrock, M. C. & Lumsdaine, A. A. “Instructional Psychology”. Annual Review Psychology, 1977,28,417-459.
    Wolf, R. M. “The Identification and measurement of environmental process variables related to intelligence”. In R. S. Soar, Teacher assessment problems and possibilities, J. of Teacher Education, 1973, 24, 205-212.
    Young, G. D., & Sassenrath, J. M. ”Student personality correlates of teacher ratings”. J. Educational Psychology, 1968,59(1),44-52.
    Zelby, L. W. “Student faculty evaluation”. Science, 1974,183,1267-1270.
    Zuckerman, M., & Wheeler, L. “To dispel fantasies about the fantasy-based measure of fear of success". Psychological Bulletin, 1975,82,932-946.

    無法下載圖示 此全文未授權公開
    QR CODE
    :::